Wenn ich den Eingang der Firma kenne und dieser nur von denen verwendet wird, klebe ich die Tags schon mal an den Eingang mit entrance=main. Gibt es in den Haus noch einen weiteren Eingang für Bewohner, bekommt dieser entrance=main und der Firmeneingang entrance=yes. Sobald dort mehrere Firmen sind, mache ich freischwebende POI. Oder wenn ich die Eingänge nicht kenne.

you removed boundary=administrative and type=boundary from this relation. and that was wrong.

walter

Hi "Sam",

never ever remove boundary tags from existing boundaries. You have "killed" a whole country.

wambacher

Ich möchte dich bitten, diesen Vandalismus zu unterlassen.

reverted.

Und nein, ich gehöre diesem Verein nicht an.

hi, war mir neu (wiki ist nichi so meine Sache). Dachte immer, das gibt es nur für richtig große Gebiete.

ok, ich kann meine kleine Auswertung entsprechend anpassen.

walluf = municipality? Ist das dein Ernst?

Gruss
walter

Hi, kibira

"z" is NOT the changeset commentar we are expecting. Please add comments which describe what you have done.

if not, you may get blocked by the Data Working Group.

Hi,
don't yet know what was going on (3 month ago) but you are right: usually i never delete boundaries but try to fix them.

may be i find the reason.

regards
walter, Germany

Great.

may be you don't know this document (i didn't)

https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/w/images/d/d8/DisputedTerritoriesInformation.pdf

it's from 2013 therefore i asked osmfoundation - it is still ok.

Regards

Walter

you should have malied me before the revert.

now it's your problem

walter

sorry, wrong link to list: https://wambachers-osm.website/images/osm/data/all_boundaries_tags.txt

fixed: changeset/59859665

btw: Goldstream and Yarmouth do have admin_level=8 but Skowkale does not.

Think they should be tagged all the same. But with or without al=8? you decide.

sorry, typing error. should be border_type=aboriginal_lands.

but why did i? there are about 33.400 admin boundaries with "border_type=X" and about 170 with boundary_type=X

see list: https://wambachers-osm.website/osm/data/all_boundaries_tags.txt

i would like to consolidate this tag - and after that add the info to the osm wiki. including used values of that tag.

walter

Hi, that can't be true: # 237508 Midland

see https://wambachers-osm.website/images/osm/snaps_2018/midland.png

regards
walter

Hi,
please do not change those very well ballenced disputed areas. This is the "OSM-view" of that critical area - so please don't change again.

Hi Fran - how should i know? ;)

regards
walter

Hi Frank,

thanks for your quick and polite answer.

yes, this area ist quite strange - espacially for people not living there.

i'll discuss this problem with some other guys (DWG). may be they know a solution.

JOSM is the best OSM-editor. There is nothing better. But the first weeks using Josm is a hard work.

regards
walter

btw: there were some errors in your last fix of that border. This has been fixed by "Garmin-User" on Suterday afternoon: changeset/59492238 The "before-upload-validator" of Josm would have informed you about that error (unclosed boundary polygon)

Ich könnte sie allerdings aus meiner lokalen History neu erzeugen - falls das notwendig sein sollte.

Hi Frederik,

möglicherweise war der Bot zu aktiv: die Landesgrenze AL2 von Nordkorea (id 192734) ist total weg und ich schaff es auch nicht, die zu restaurieren

Gruss
walter