Hi, is there an import going on?
nobody can enter so much data in so short time.

walter

Hi,

you killed the admin boundary of Thailand and this region too.

Please never ever modify relations, which you don't know about.

regards
walter

see: changeset/52919301

Hi, you KILLED the bounday of sweden.

plese never ever touch a boundary with iD.

walter

Hi, you are right. this is an disputed area.

BUT: it is still an adminitrative area too. And that is more important to osm.

all three objects (relation and the two boundaries in the north and south are tagged as "disputed". and that is enough.

changed it back to adminitrative.

regards
walter

kein problem.

Gruss
walter

Aber georg, es weiss doch jeder (oder sollte wissen), dass die PLZ-Gebiete eine note haben. Ist nicht toll, aber historisch gewachsen. hab es korrigiert.

ansonsten: https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?pid=666075#p666075

Hi, you did it again.

i had to fix this again.
a) if you think, your solutioin is correct, please enter this discussion and give us some infos.
b) your solution was TECHNICALLY wrong too. Both boundaries of Spain and Morocco were damaged. Ways were missing and the boundaries have not been closed. This is very poor work. Don't touch any relation if you can't handle them.

DWG has been informed and you will be contacted by them.

Hi danny,

had to close two boundaries:
see https://wambachers-osm.website/index.php/10-osm-reports/1029-countries-compare-2017-09-23

changeset/52301339

Regards
walter, germany

Hi, please don't touch the boundaries of spain/morocco. this is a critical area and must not be modified by anobody. The current situation (before your changes) is created, accepted and monitored by the Data Working Group (DWG) - and me.

i reverted your changes to get the old version.

DWG has been informed.

btw: Please use meaningfull and informative changeset comments.

Regards
walter

yes, sorry about that.

regards
walter

Please don't tuch any boundary in this area. it it very critical and should not be chabnged by anyone. A lot of Reverts had to be done by the DATA WORKING GROUP and others.

The current state - before your changes - is the official OSM decision. again: don't think, that you (in ste states) do know it better.

If you want to fix boundaries, take care of your own country. The USA has very bad and wrong boundaries on all levels. Even Albania or Mali is better.

walter

weil ich das eventuell nicht erkannt habe?

nun, der Tag ist so oder so nicht wertvoll. Stammt aus einen - damals miserablen und auch wohl nicht angemeldeten - Shape-Import und das ganze ist über ein jahr her. kannst es ja zurückdrehen, ich sehe allerdings keinen Sinn darin

Hi Didier, i know that you are a experenced mapper, but last day you did a lot of errors in DOM.

you "killed" 18 (eighteen!!) AL4-Boundaries in DOM by changing them without care.

see list: https://wambachers-osm.website/index.php/10-osm-reports/1021-countries-compare-2017-09-15

all 18 Missings or Area Changes of DOM are result of your work.

detail: relation/3421245

remember the old rule: before editing a boundary, take care about the other members of other relations.

walter/Germany

a marketplace is NOT a building

walter

Hi, there are many problems with your last edits.
you changed disputed admin boundaries of india, bhutan and china. because there are no international accepted changes (i.g. in the UN), you must not change the international boundaries in osm. event the "discussion" between india and china about the western area of bhutan is not closed. there is no international agreement about that.

btw: you "killed" the boundaries of three countries -. china included.

see [url=https://wambachers-osm.website/images/osm/snaps_2017/chn_btn_ind.png][img]https://wambachers-osm.website/images/osm/snaps_2017/tn_chn_btn_ind.png[/img][/url]

data working group (DWG) has been contacted and i'm waiting for their action - usually a full revert.

walter

HI, please STOP editing in this AREA until you answer our questions. YOU WILL BE BLOCKED OTHERWISE

save your time, your work may be reverted.

Hi, please stop this activities asap. the area of doklam is still disputet. there is no OFFICIAL agreement between all three states yet.

data working group (DWG) is informed and your changes will be reverted until the agreement is ok

Hi, can you tell me one reason why you destroid the national boundary of bangladesch?

walter

oops, i only checked all ADMIN boundaries.
thanks for fixing the others