tomhukins's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 34868175 | Hi, I reclassified three power=line ways added in this changeset as power=minor_line in changeset/80548996 as that seemed like a more suitable description to me. |
|
| 74992070 | I've fixed this in changeset/80389686 and added a note to discourage further mistakes. |
|
| 74992070 | Why have you tagged way/23608133 as a tunnel? It's a bridge. |
|
| 78926704 | Thank you for adding a note to mention that this cafe has closed. However, it's still tagged as a cafe. You might want to consider using the changeset/78922133 approach so that it's no longer considered an functioning cafe. |
|
| 77369250 | Hi, you requested a review for this edit: I notice you tagged way/746127935#map=19/54.17175/-6.34371 using addr:housenumber and addr:street but the others, such as way/746252531 have a "name" that looks like it should be an addr:housenumber instead (ideally with the street name too). Also, the buildings are tagged "building=yes" which is fine, but I suspect "building=house" would be more descriptive. Thank you for taking the time to help improve the map. |
|
| 77407665 | This looks like spam. You seem to have made little effort to understand how to tag properly for OpenStreetMap to help improve the data. It's great that you want to help improve the map, but please don't invent your own tags: take some time to understand how things work here. |
|
| 77376846 | Hi, welcome to OpenStreetMap! Thank you for helping to improve the map. |
|
| 77398467 | Hi, you asked for a review of your changes. Firstly, welcome to OpenStreetMap! Your work looks good to me. If you have any more details about the buildings you added, such as addresses or names of businesses that operate from the industrial buildings, it would be helpful to add them. I notice another mapper has already marked the swimming pool you added as private: way/747921597/history Thank you very much for your helpful improvements to the map. |
|
| 77287663 | Hi, thank you very much for helping to improve the map. I notice you requested a review of your changes. I have made a few modifications at changeset/77440793. I get the impression the Kempton Steam Museum is the name of the museum, so belongs in the "name" tag, but the organisation that runs it "Kempton Great Engines Trust" belongs in the "operator" tag. Likewise, I expect the road to the south is managed by them rather than named after them. Also, the road leading to the petrol station probably isn't named "Shell". The petrol station itself already has this information at way/243794318. If you have more information about the bus stops you modified, you might want to follow the process described at osm.wiki/NaPTAN/Surveying_and_Merging_NaPTAN_and_OSM_data. Thanks again for your helpful work. Feel free to fix my changes if you think they're wrong, and have fun improving the map in future. |
|
| 77343760 | Hi, you requested a review of your changes. I notice you have left the operator tag as "Cocum" which seems like a mistake and the FHRS ID 200123 is for Cocum - I found it by following the "Merton" link from https://ratings.food.gov.uk/open-data/en-GB. I suggest removing both these tags. What do you think? Thank you for helping to improve the map. |
|
| 77390533 | Hi, you requested a review of your changes. I don't know the area, but the tags you've used look sensible and helpful to me. Thank you for improving the map. |
|
| 77074867 | Hi, thank you for fixing my mistake :) |
|
| 66143896 | I notice you tagged Wilton Hall as a restaurant: way/200798685/history - do you think that's the best description for it? Until recently, it was a hall for music, dance and other events. I'd expect that still to be the case. |
|
| 60645891 | Thank you for your explanation. I recognise those features and always assumed they were decorative. I never knew about their original use. |
|
| 60645891 | Hi, are you sure these exist? I've walked along here many times and never seen anything that even vaguely resembles a pillbox. |
|
| 67105345 | Hi, this changeset moves Euro Halal node/6152557050 into Tesco car park. I assume that's a mistake, so I've moved it back to its previous location in changeset/77014998 |
|
| 72511461 | Does the building you added at way/706357163 overlap Powerhouse Lane? This seems unlikely. |
|
| 73279794 | It looks like you've deleted lots of nodes and created new nodes with the same information. This means the history of the old nodes is now lost. Please try to avoid doing this in future. |
|
| 66868567 | I'm fairly sure it's a mistake, so I removed it in changeset/73404584 |
|
| 72710924 | I'm fairly sure it's a mistake, so I removed it in changeset/73404584 |