OpenStreetMap
ralley's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 98594304 | Glacier Burn Track is alrady mapped as way way/755484272
|
|
| 98479028 | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. The normal practice in New Zealand is not to add sidewalks as seperate ways but instead use the "refinement of highway" approach where sidewalk tags are added to the parent road instead. See sidewalk=* Using that method it is generally much easier to maintain topological correctness for routing.
|
|
| 98464314 | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. When adding phone numbers please use ITU-T E.164 format as per phone=*
|
|
| 98264555 | Please don't edit the underlying map in an attempt to create personalised routes. There are applications which use OSM as a base map with which you can create routes instead.
|
|
| 97924961 | Why have you put layer=-1 on way/898090359 ? It is visible in aerial imagery so is not underground.
|
|
| 97923397 | Also Mokoroa Falls Track is still closed according to DOC (https://www.doc.govt.nz/parks-and-recreation/places-to-go/auckland/places/muriwai-and-te-henga-area/tracks/mokoroa-falls-track/), and Goldie Bush Walkway (https://www.doc.govt.nz/parks-and-recreation/places-to-go/auckland/places/muriwai-and-te-henga-area/tracks/goldie-bush-walkway/) are closed but will now appear as open on the map
|
|
| 97923397 | Mokoroa Stream Track is closed according to DOC (see https://www.doc.govt.nz/parks-and-recreation/places-to-go/auckland/places/muriwai-and-te-henga-area/tracks/mokoroa-stream-track/) but you have added back foot=yes which marks it as open. Is it truely re-opened?
|
|
| 97801227 | Eliot has cleared this up in the comments on changeset/6750217 |
|
| 97726494 | Why have you removed the building tags from these?
|
|
| 97691052 | Sorry I just realised tagging the ditch (way/459979616) with name="Water Race" was done in a previous changeset by another user.
|
|
| 97691052 | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits, please don't add generic descriptions to the name field: osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only
|
|
| 97590515 | Thanks for addressing that. |
|
| 97590515 | Please dont put descriptions like "Access track (approx only)" in the name fields - it is for genuine names only: osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only
|
|
| 97525656 | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. One thing instead of the service road and the track connecting to the car park polygon they should be extended to meet inside the polygon. in this way routers will make the connection.
|
|
| 97402934 | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits - unfortunately a POI for a park run does not belong in OSM. As a map only physical entities that can be verified on the ground should be added. See the on-the-ground rule at osm.wiki/How_We_Map
|
|
| 97246105 | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. A quick pointer: many buildings in NZ consist only of 90 degree corners. You can enforce this in the Id editor by selecting the outline, right clicking and choosing "Square" (shortcut "Q").
|
|
| 97248502 | Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits. Please be careful and look out for warnings from the editor - this change dragged a node of Fernham Way to the South, I've fixed it.
|
|
| 96563317 | The Caltex fuel station is already tagged and has been for over 4 years, please don't create duplicates
|
|
| 95782577 | That looks better, thanks for that |
|
| 96030844 | Then it gets a bit fuzzy. My approach is to map as a seperate way if the gap is roughly >4m or not strictly parallel but it's a value judgement.
|