Hi, deleting all this seems kind of questionable. By deleting the existing library building, you removed a lot of other information about the library that was in the tags of that way. You also deleted some roof-only sections of the building. You mention fixes to pedestrian areas, but I'm not clear what improvements you made to them. Indoor mapping doesn't always "look good" in a standard rendering but in general if the data is accurate, there needs to be a very good reason to redo/remove it.

Welcome to OSM and thanks for adding to the map! In a strip mall like this, it would be better practice to create a building for the entire structure, and then add nodes for each business within the mall, rather than create individual areas for only some of the stores. Also note, landuse tags should not be used on buildings or stores. Teppanyaki Grill should probably be tagged amenity=restaurant, Duluth Trading should be shop=clothes, etc.

Hi, I notice you previously updated the address of this point, but didn't move its location to the new address--are you planning to do that? Also, you might want to add an office tag if that's appropriate (see office=* for values)

Hi and welcome to OSM! I see you flagged "review requested" and these edits look good to me. For businesses, you might also consider adding address, phone #, website, and (if you're feeling adventurous) opening hours. Happy mapping!

Hi, wondering why you created this Edgewood College way that includes the High School and Campus School too? The college is just a part of this area, and they are all independent though related schools. (ie see https://www.edgewood.edu/docs/default-source/aboutdocs/directions/campusmap.pdf)

Hi, it appears you uploaded a bunch of duplicate nodes in this changeset--can you please clean that up?

As Ellen Ripley said to Cpl Hicks, "it's the only way to be sure" :)

Thanks!

what is the source for this data? it appears to be an apartment building

Hi, I know this is old, but this path seems incorrect--features should generally be able to be seen on the ground and verified. The horse fest path looks like it's a temporary feature? If so it should be removed.

Congrats! Looks like a cool place.

Hi, I am a local mapper and noticed the recent edits to this node's tags. I think amenity=events_venue would be the best tag, as amenity=community_centre is for public places, and this appears to be a private venue.

Hi, I noticed you created these walking paths as one long line. Instead of doing this and creating overlapping paths, you should create smaller lines that connect to each other at nodes. Thanks for mapping!

Hi, these buildings with an inner courtyard should be done as multipolygons. See https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/22542/how-do-i-map-an-island-in-a-lake-using-id-editor-and-the-multipolygon-tag for more info.

Hi it looks like you're unsure about the correct tag for this. FYI, if you want to use fitness_centre, the correct key is leisure not amenity. See leisure=fitness_centre

It seems this changeset includes many duplicated items from changeset/52642326. Please take a look and fix this. Thanks!

Good question! I did find something on the wiki that might work: man_made=cutline, cutline=firebreak man_made=cutline I doubt it'll be displayed on one of the "standard" maps, but it will be in the database and could be shown in a custom rendering.

I noticed you didn't add any tags to the Waialea Fuelbreak like you did with the Waikoloa one--is there a reason for that?

Hi Jerrod, I've noticed that some of your changes to the map are very specific to you. Data added to OSM should be features "on the ground" that are verifiable--see osm.wiki/Good_practice Therefore, naming something as "Jerrod's Favorite" is not appropriate, although mapping something (like a meadow you use for hunting) is fine.

Welcome and thanks for adding to the map! One thing I'd recommend changing is the open area tagging (way/528576060) from highway=footway to highway=pedestrian. Also for bonus points you could add type and/or capacity info to the bicycle parking :)