Hi, should the leisure=fitness node be leisure=fitness_station?

Hi, I noticed you added a lot of detail for a disc golf course, but tagged incorrectly as a regular golf course. Please use disc_golf=tee or disc_golf=basket (and maybe disc_golf=hole) as mentioned on the wiki: osm.wiki/Disc_golf#Currently_used_tags As mentioned there, you can group these together with a relation, and use the leisure=disc_golf_course tag for the whole thing.

Hi, this changeset seems to have some duplicate buildings with changeset/52293743. For ex, see houses on west side of Jackson Trail

Hi, wondering what the thinking is on the "Rogers" rectangle? If it's supposed to be for the city, that already has a boundary relation: relation/137442

Hi, I noticed that the relation for Pohakuloa Training Area (relation/7411335) includes some small areas to the north of Pupukea Paalaa Uka Military Road. I am not local, but in looking at the imagery there, it's not obvious that those small areas are actually military areas. Maybe they were formerly gates or something. Do you have some way to verify that they are all currently military areas, and part of Pohakuloa?

Hi, I noticed some of these driveways (ie near Square Lake) are untagged--please take a look and tag them. You can also see them here: http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=tagging&lon=-92.80896&lat=45.14732&zoom=14&opacity=0.75

In this changeset, you added two place=neighbourhood nodes, but no name or other information. Please add that if you know it, or consider removing them if the tag doesn't fit (see place=neighbourhood)

Thanks! I haven't been that way lately so haven't kept track of the changes.

Thanks for fixing. Are the road ways that connect to the bridge correct too? They are tagged cycleway=lane.

Hi, just a quick note that the correct key for fitness centres is leisure, not amenity (see leisure=fitness_centre). Cheers

Hi just a quick note that the correct tag for fitness centres is leisure, not amenity. (see leisure=fitness_centre) Happy mapping!

Hi, this data looks like it could be fictional. 1) no evidence of water (much less lakes) in the imagery, 2) this looks like a residence not a park, 3) no record of a park here in an internet search. Please give sources for these edits. Thanks!

Hi, I notice you added a leisure=gym tag. FYI, this should probably be tagged leisure=fitness_centre. See leisure=fitness_centre

Hi, I notice you added a leisure=gym tag. FYI, this should probably be tagged leisure=fitness_centre. See leisure=fitness_centre

FYI, self-intersections reported in OSM Inspector: http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=-93.12650&lat=44.66436&zoom=16&opacity=0.94

Just an FYI that two buildings in this changeset are flagged for self-intersection errors in OSM Inspector: http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=-93.16259&lat=44.70607&zoom=16&opacity=0.94

Not sure what to do about it now, but if you added name:eo to the Mississippi River relation, why would you also add it to each segment???

I know this is an older edit, but I noticed that the opening_hours for Mackenthun's isn't the right format. A tutorial is here for future reference (or if you want to fix this): opening_hours=*/Tutorial

Thanks for contributing to OpenStreetMap! Just wanted to point out that the footpath east of the parking lot here is incorrectly mapped: a way should not double back over itself. I would probably just make each of these little loops separate ways. In case you're interested, I found this using one of the OSM QA tools, OSM Inspector: http://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=geometry&lon=-92.65319&lat=45.41793&zoom=18&opacity=0.93

@userJeff, OpenStreetMap is at core a project to create data which can be used to make maps, do routing, etc. Over years, guidelines have formed about the best way to do that, such as "map what's on the ground". You are mostly talking about the rendering of how the data looks and making assumptions about what *map* users want. However, what is most important to OSM is making the actual data as accurate as we can, so different *data* users can use it to make the maps, routers, or other things that they want. So, does the park actually go into the middle of the road? No, it stops next to the road. Therefore don't attach the park to the road. It may not seem relevant to you now, but there are places where highly detailed mapping is being done, and mapping this way will make it harder for future editors. Thanks