OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
137610012

Hi,
this changeset (again) created wrong tags:

level = 1 -> this should be 'levels'

nb_garage -> this tag should not appear in OSM, what does it mean?

137409727

These cases should be covered by restriction = no_stopping / no_standing / no_parking.

Wiki says that the UK "no waiting" translates to no_parking which seems to make sense.

Maybe you can extend the table for the restriction tag with a hint about UK street markings?

137409727

I'm not fully aware of the implications of a double yellow line in the UK, but wouldn't "parking lane is present but stopping is forbidden" be

parking:both = lane
parking:both:restriction = no_stopping
?

137409727

Tagging should reflect the legal situation. Physically you can park your car diagonally on a 3 lane motorway... but legally you're not allowed (and shouldn't for obvious reasons)

137409727

Hi,
the parking tags you used here are outdated. Please have a look at the current tagging scheme:
osm.wiki/Street_parking

137495896

Hi,
you added many *:2022 tags here for parking that have been removed (as I understand it).

Actually most of the tags can be removed, just leaving "was:amenity=parking_space" to prevent other users from adding them again?

137308841

I tested 3 or 4 and none was working. E.g. https://www.bcmarinetrails.org/map_site/kaikash-creek

137384608

Hi,
the tag "horsepowerlimit" is not used in other places. Can you explain what is allowed here?

137308841

Hi,
the website links you added here don't work, they just redirect to a sign-up page. And, please don't use description tags for extensive texts - OSM is not the right place for this.

137330751

Please improve your QA procedures. I fix errors made by Grab employees almost every day. At least pay attention to warnings and errors shown by the JOSM validator!

136629284

Hi,
"surface:colour" is perfectly fine and the version that has more use cases.
I somehow prefer the shorter version (which also exists). I think that 'surface' is redundant - what else could be the color of a path but the surface?

The reason for my edit was a different one: it's "colour" (British spelling) and not "color"

137270359

Hi,
you used a couple 'recycling' tags here that are not used in other places. Could you check these? All tags should be in English and preferably only those listed in the wiki should be used. See
amenity=recycling

136917764

Hi,
we do have several different tags for checkpoints, e.g. by police. We also have tags for fire lookouts.
But I think there's nothing for this special case.

How about some generic tagging and a description:

amenity = checkpoint (used 200 times in various contexts)
access:conditional = yes @ Jun 15 - Nov 30; no @ Dec 01 - Jun 14
description = ... fire prevention ... guard ... no access
operator = XY

Maybe access=private or permit is better depending on the actual situation

Make sure the node is part of the highway so that a router sees the barrier.

66991565

Hi,
you added a couple of hour_on, hour_off tags on this road. Could you describe what they refer to?

124939141

Hi,
there are a couple of places with an "N50" tag - was this added by mistake or is it a useful reference number?

137104943

Im Detail betrachtet sind es nicht nur 40 direkte Duplikate sondern auch hunderte von Geomtriefehlern die der Validator nicht findet, z.B. Knoten direkt nebeneinander die aber verbunden werden müssten, aufgeteilte Gebäude die maximal building:part wären.

136992934

Ok.
You don't need to write a full proposal right away. Just head to the tagging section of the OSM forum and describe your idea to see how the general response is:
https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/general/tagging/70

137104943

Außerdem wurde hier von mindestens 40 Gebäuden Duplikate erzeugt, wie auch immer das passiert ist.

137155460

Hi,
welcome to OSM!
Could you explain what these two nodes represent?

Please have a look to the documented tags in the wiki or the presets in your editor and add one of these - only well-defined tags can be understood by other mappers and can be shown on maps and in applications.

137125976

Please stop uploading the same dataset again and again. All these >11000 objects don't contain any valid tag. I reverted theses edits.

If these points actually contain any useful data for OSM, please follow our import rules before trying to upload them again:
osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines