OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
79577457

The problem with world changeset is that many QA tools don't handle it well (your changeset appears to cover many countries where you haven't changed any items).
qa tools could handle it better but the human who sees the bbox of a changeset has to check by hand some objects to get an idea of where you have made changes.
that's the main concern: indigestible for humans.

unnamed localities can sometimes be understandable if a contributor remembers seeing the sign announcing a locality without remembering the name (or he uses mapillary but the picture is not good enough to read the name). he still adds useful information and someone will complete it another day.
so I'm against their removal, but especially mass editions of this kind should be discussed on the talk list https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
So removing the fixme you previously add seem the best thing todo before any other world fix.

Regards,
Marc

79577457

Hello,
can you please :
- avoid changeset spanning the word. split at the country level at least.
- adding unneeded fixme.
if a object doesn't have a name tag, the name tag is missing. no need to add fixme "tag X is not there".
- use a better source value. if I understand correctly, you have removed current bad value (like population=C) or change somes bad value ((like population=no) to =0.
if all the data comes from osm, it's source=extrapolation.
if some of the data comes from osm and some comes from elsewhere, it would have been clearer with more than one changeset
Regards,
Marc

50831453

Hello,
node/5013701470
what's the meaning of "pouze během LFŠ"
it's a temporary event ? it's a temporary event that took place and ended? or it's a recurring event? at least that doesn't sound like a name.

79146537

le tag source a l'air détourné de son objectif, ici cet objet n'a même aucun nom et pourtant un mention a été faite node/6847161629
le tag source est mis sur le changeset lorsqu'il concerne la source réelle du changement. il n'a pas vocation à polluer la base en le copiant sur les objets modifiés pour faire de la pub et sans aucun rapport avec la modification

79146134

Bonjour,
node/307976382
quel est le sens de cette modif ?
pourriez-vous faire des modifs plus petites mais plus compréhensible ?
par ailleurs les éditions de masses doivent faire l'objet d'une procédure, pour éviter les soucis de qualité comme celui-ci
osm.wiki/FR:Politique_de_modification_automatis%C3%A9e

64767397

Hello,
way/647620950
what's the meaning of BSP/GSP ?

48402851

it seems that the whole area is a park, the tourism=camp_site is only a part of it.
and maybe a skateboard park also exist but only a part of the whole park

48402851

Hello,
can you review way/491420513 ?
what's this ? a tourism=camp_site (a site where ppl can spend their holidays in a tent and/or caravan ?
a leisure=park ? where ppl can walk.
a skate board pitch ? but a part of it is for golf

55619271

Hello,
what did you mean with this changeset ?
are those 4 campsite 4 standalone basic campsite ? or a part of a one-only campsite ?

44328005

Hello,
are thos 2 camp_pitch a part of this camp_site ?
node/4549584449
node/4549584449
node/2420110668
Regards

77147909

Hello,
way/745995001
wha'ts that ?
a tourism=camp_pitch is a part of a tourism=camp_site, but I don't see any tourism=camp_site including it
regards

71802634

Hello,
thanks for the update.
can you draw the scope of the whole tourism=camp_site ? does it have 3 tourism=camp_pitch ? (you update one of them but not the 2 others)
regards

69757725

thanks

76480379

So this location is a reception desk of a tourism=camp_site ?

if the extent of the tourism=camp_site is not known, it is better to keep it as a node (but not the same node for tourism=camp_site and amenity=reception_desk)

72040619

Hello,
way/702613440
what's this ?
a tourism=camp_pitch ?
or a duplicate of the whole node/1345663241 ?
Regards,
Marc

69757725

Hello,
node/6440087042
what did you mean with it ?
you want to map one of the several tourism=camp_pitch ?
or it's a duplicate of the whole tourism=camp_site way/203469126 ?
Regards,
Marc

76480379

Hello Jakka,
node/6936583936
what's this ?
a reception desk ? a cabin inside a tourism=camp_site ? a reception desk inside a cabin ?
wouldn't it be better to split things into 2-3 objects? an area for tourism=camp_site (camp_site allows to define the quality of the camping) and an amenity=reception_desk object? building=cabin on the building it-selft.
moreover the controversial key camp_site defines if it is the main activity, secondary or place without activity
Regards,
Marc

54846711

Hello,
I just read you have been there 2 years ago.
can you help me to understand what's this :
node/1720571864
the national bank also have a poor localisation
the sultan palace is duplicate.
thanks

72154320

Hello,
For ex this one is for the 20th avenue, not the 26h
node/6606621774

69296601

Bonjour Jim005,
où en est-tu dans la demande à la source pour l'autorisation d'utilisation de leur base de donné ?