jptolosa's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 36847282 | Hola,
|
|
| 39701308 | Hello naoliv,
|
|
| 25784874 | According international laws, the coastline of a man-made island can not be used to measure the outer of a territorial sea, e.g. in Dubai. |
|
| 37456486 | Hello bufemc, This boundary was already tagged as boundary=maritime, then adding the tag maritime=yes is redundant. You can see in the wiki that maritime=yes should be used only with boundary=administrative: boundary=maritime Regards. |
|
| 39789259 | I already fixed all of your other same errors, I think.
|
|
| 39789259 | The history doesn't lie: you did these deletions. I know it was not your intention, but if you want to contribute also you must instruct.
|
|
| 39802917 | Estuary of a river is a maritime water body. Then my tagging natural=coastline is correct and you tagging waterway=riverbank is incorrect. |
|
| 39789259 | You have deleted natural=coastline from shoreline of Isla Látimer and part of Isla Madre de Dios. Now Isla Látimer has disappeared from mapnik rendering and Isla Madre de Dios has been "cutted". I think I said natural=coastline tag only can be used in segments, not in nodes neither relations. The wiki info is clear. Please more careful the next time. And source=PGS should not be shifted from the coastline segment to multipolygon relation.
|
|
| 39639313 | I remove tags from the ways of the relation, because the info is already inside the relation. Tagging both, ways and relations is redundant, except for tag natural=coastline and source=*. |
|
| 39488854 | Please don't add nodes to a multipolygon. It only accepts ways as members. |
|
| 39485205 | Can you tell me which is the Iris Island? I think this is a peninsula. |
|
| 39648886 | You should not remove natural=coastline tag from a way tagged as place=island or place=islet, because it will disappear from the map. |
|
| 39650926 | Already exists a multipolygon for Isla Duque de York. You should not put the name in outer rings of the multipolygon (on the coastline). It doesn't produce any effect or can produce an undesired effect.
|
|
| 38315045 | @Rub21
|
|
| 39513228 | boundary=administrative tag should not be used to delimit national parks and nature reserves. |
|
| 38315045 | Hello Michael.
Here you have two differents sources about the worldwide coastline compress in a shapefile and you can see the great mistake: https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/mgg/shorelines/data/gshhg/latest/ http://www.naturalearthdata.com/downloads/10m-physical-vectors/10m-coastline/ Please rethink your changeset.
|
|
| 35370184 | I would be grateful to you if you are capable to do it. There is an user who created all chilean maritime boundaries. You can see quality of them is very fine, generated by a script. I wrote to him a while ago. He was disposed to share his script, but he forgot to answer me again. Maybe you can write him about this again. Here is his changeset: changeset/4232326 Regards. |
|
| 35370184 | Hello Martien,
You can see the discussion here: changeset/33040192 |
|
| 38772885 | Thanks for the observation. Old limit was in the mouth of the river. |
|
| 18302625 | Thanks for the info. |