OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
42475210

Where did you get the stream data from? They are not visible in the Bing aerial imagery due to trees but I don't want to assume you plagiarized them from another map.

51002678

Are you sure you tagged the correct way? This road should be destination=沙田 Sha Tin.

51071446

osm.wiki/Multilingual_names#China 宣稱,英文名字、拼音不應該在"name=*"寫。

51071446

大陸物品的“name=*”不是應該只有中文的名字嗎?而且“Canton”不是廣州的英文名字,是Guangzhou。

51017863

hi, you created a few empty nodes ('797–'800) which aren't connected to anything. should they be deleted?

50986338

(Just noting that you should use the newly available DigitalGlobe imagery instead of Bing since it's much less distorted and doesn't have any coverage issues here.)

50727248

Probably best to leave the data until the question on help.osm is resolved, as I'm not entirely sure and there's still the option of asking for government permission to waive the conditions.

50727248

https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/57395/copying-of-survey-points-and-other-things

50727248

Yes, but "free with conditions" does not mean "open source and also compatible with the ODbL", especially because of the additional requirements for government attribution and compliance with the Terms of Use. I'll ask on help.openstreetmap.org.

50727248

Hi, are you sure copying this data is allowed? The linked website has a copyright claim and does not appear to be license-compatible.

50153299

public_transport=platform is applied to all platforms (bus, train, light rail, subway, etc.) part of a public transport system, regardless of type. railway=platform is for all rail platforms. Since these platforms are both for railway vehicles and in a public transport system they should have both.

50153299

Why did you remove public_transport tags?

49770180

Do you have data for the other 8 districts?

48087436

the roads don't exist currently and have been closed for several years now due to construction work

48628213

hi, it would be very helpful if you also added the Chinese names of establishments. thanks

47069471

Do these exist? All the exits should have been added already.

47628789

also, note that Mapbox imagery can be low-quality so cross-reference using Bing imagery if it's not distorted

47628789

thanks for contributing to OSM. it would be helpful if you used a more descriptive changeset summary

37356088

(Reverted via MapRoulette.)

37349270

(Reverted via MapRoulette.)