OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
123141109

no, la questione non è se si ferma su richiesta, ma se ci sono deviatori. Se ci passano solo binari senza che i treni possono cambiare binario è un "halt" e non una "station", in Italia i nomi sono "fermata" e "stazione".

121502877

Ciao Michele, ho notato che hai cambiato railway=stop in railway=stop;station qui node/24969004
Si dovrebbe avere al meno 2 elementi distinti per questo, uno per la station e uno per ogni direzione la posizione dove ferma (stop)

53561593

I don't know about Finland, and whether it has been discussed there, but the edit was not limited to Finland. Generally, all mass edits require public discussion and approval. I question that you "fixed" the tags, because "addr:unit" is not the same as "addr:staircase".

123141109

Ciao, ho notato che hai cambiato la fermata Stella Polare da railway=halt in railway=station, mi sembra che era giusto prima.
Ciao,
Martin

53561593

keimo, are you going to revert your undiscussed mass edit?

112981744

Hi, I also noticed the altitude tags. What is the unit, is it meters? Are these things levitating above the ground or did you intend to map the elevation of the ground where they stand on?
If these are thought to be meters, e.g. 818.9404396, the indicated precision is between micrometers and nanometers, very small stuff that is, I would encourage you to reflect about measurement accuracy as well as the reference height (e.g. if there is a grain of sand below your measuring device it will already change the number, unevenness of the ground etc.), and eventually round these numbers.

31899393

jedenfalls war es damals ein Eingang für Behinderte und nicht ein ungenutzter Eingang

31899393

Habe es doch gefunden, war gar nicht so schwer ;-)
node/3588048319
damit ist wheelchair=yes gemeint, bzw. dürfen da glaube ich nur Menschen mit Gehbehinderung den Aufzug benutzen, war da aber schon Jahre nicht mehr und kann es nicht genau sagen ob das noch aktuell ist und der Aufzug noch funktioniert.

31899393

gute Frage nach 9 Jahren, könntest Du evtl. einen Link auf das Objekt posten bzw. sagen, wo genau, dann muss ich es nicht raussuchen?

158241004

Ciao fb552,
sì, per ogni stazione ci dovrebbe essere solo un railway=station (o nel caso della fermata railway=halt), e questo può essere un area oppure un nodo (l'area è meglio secondome). Invece per l'edificio della stazione è sufficiente essere incluso nell'area della stazione, e secondo il tipo normalmente ha il tag building=train_station.
Ciao,
Martin

158241004

Ciao fb552, ho notato che hai creato una serie di doppioni delle stazioni, perché hai aggiunto all'edificio della stazione il tag per la stazione ferroviaria (railway=station), ma questo già era presente sulla stazione (tutto il perimetro dove si trova la stazione, la banchina, i binari etc.). Ti chiedo gentilmente di togliere i doppioni, perché altrimenti le stazioni sono contenuti due volte.

Grazie,
Martin

53561593

I don't think we should continue to pretend it is ok to use addr:unit for staircases, because these are quite different things, an addr:unit is typically referring to an individual address, while addr:staircase is usually referring to many addresses (everybody who has access through this staircase).
The claim that addr:unit would be a suitable replacement was introduced just 2 years ago, and I am going to revert it: osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Key%3Aaddr%3Astaircase&type=revision&diff=2321398&oldid=2290621 because it creates inconsistency with the definition of addr:unit

There is no time limit to complain about undiscussed mass edits, or is there?

53561593

please revert the (undiscussed, global) retagging of addr:staircase to addr:unit, they are different things

53676260

please revert the (undiscussed, global) retagging of addr:staircase to addr:unit, they are different things

53562477

please revert the (undiscussed, global) retagging of addr:staircase to addr:unit, they are different things

53564346

please revert the (undiscussed, global) retagging of addr:staircase to addr:unit, they are different things

53501787

please revert the (undiscussed, global) retagging of addr:staircase to addr:unit, they are different things

53501842

please revert the (undiscussed, global) retagging of addr:staircase to addr:unit, they are different things

53677842

please revert the (undiscussed, global) retagging of addr:staircase to addr:unit, they are different things

53918699

please revert the (undiscussed, global) retagging of addr:staircase to addr:unit, they are different things