OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
136092626

чому немає загального тега "name"?

node/1876496471

135996798

*added name:uk tag

135954055

reverted as broken changeset/135954113

135953798

reverted as broken in changeset/135954031

135892735

so you deleted ukrainian names for objects from russia and this is official position of DWG?

135881588

so you deleted ukrainian names for objects from russia and this is official position of DWG?

135867839

ok.

but please answer me about double standards: when russian translate something in Ukraine we are just "ok", but something is translted in russia - it is forbidden.

is it fair rules?

135873017

any propositions what it should be?..

because of higher type than "minor_distribution" is "distribution" - this is for regional substations

135791056

why Eiffel Tower in France have russian translation way/5013364 ? it has such name? no. why it is translated into russian? error? look how much errors in France https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1uE3why Brandenburg Gate in Germany have russian translation way/518071791 ? it has such name? no. why it is translated into russian? error? look how much errors in Germany https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1uE6
what you will say now? you see how much translated objects are? they are all errors?

Now look at wikipedia about language in russia:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russia#Language
"... in 2010... and 1.1 million spoke Ukrainian."
when we look at diagram about population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Ethnic_groups_in_Russia_of_more_than_1_million_people_2010_Census_English.pngwe will see 2 millions of ukrainians live in russia.

thats why I translate regions and other objects into ukrainian language. because this is done over entire world - there are a lots of translations of object that in reality didnot have names placed in ex. "name:ru" tags.

so I will continue to translate and please re-read this note again if you have any concerns.

135791056

you gived only few examples, that are errors than can happend, but what about of hundreds of names that you reverted? it seems like you dont know the purpose of name:lang tags, so before next change read the the docs and dont delete a lots of work

135802311

what did you mean by "nonexistent names"? it is translation that is for tags name:lang are supposed for

135790562

You are wrong, the translation is needed so that foreign language users can find the necessary points of interest on the map. therefore return all the changes back or according to your logic there can be no other translation?

135790033

You are wrong, the translation is needed so that foreign language users can find the necessary points of interest on the map. therefore return all the changes back or according to your logic there can be no other translation?

135790013

You are wrong, the translation is needed so that foreign language users can find the necessary points of interest on the map. therefore return all the changes back or according to your logic there can be no other translation?

135789973

You are wrong, the translation is needed so that foreign language users can find the necessary points of interest on the map. therefore return all the changes back or according to your logic there can be no other translation?

135789901

You are wrong, the translation is needed so that foreign language users can find the necessary points of interest on the map. therefore return all the changes back or according to your logic there can be no other translation?

135789837

You are wrong, the translation is needed so that foreign language users can find the necessary points of interest on the map. therefore return all the changes back or according to your logic there can be no other translation?

135796825

You are wrong, the translation is needed so that foreign language users can find the necessary points of interest on the map. therefore return all the changes back or according to your logic there can be no other translation?

135791056

You are wrong, the translation is needed so that foreign language users can find the necessary points of interest on the map. therefore return all the changes back or according to your logic there can be no other translation?

133267582

промилки трапляються, тоді на допомогу приходять інші маппери :)