Hi,

This one too fails PTV2 .. see
https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=pubtrans_routes&lon=149.79565&lat=-34.69624&zoom=10&overlays=ptv2_routes_,ptv2_routes_valid,ptv2_routes_invalid,ptv2_error_,ptv2_error_ways,ptv2_error_nodes

Hi,
This fails for public transport version 2...
Unordered gap in ways
Stop not on way
unknown role...

See https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=pubtrans_routes&lon=149.89453&lat=-33.22812&zoom=9&overlays=ptv2_routes_,ptv2_routes_valid,ptv2_routes_invalid,ptv2_error_,ptv2_error_ways,ptv2_error_nodes

Good.

I would try to fit the route members to fit into either 'Public Transport version 1' or, my preference, 'Public Transport version 2'.

I did a simple guide to v2 on @Warin61/diary/45106, mainly so I could refer to it when I got confused! Sometimes the OSM wiki is not the best for a quick guide - which is what I want most of the time.

Been discussing this on the talk-au list ... There is a use of the key 'passenger' that I was not aware of .. passenger=tourist may be a good tag to add to your routes.

Hi,
Is this 'tour' a one off .. or going to be a regular thing?

Hi,
The name tag should be used for the name only - see osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only

I suggest using the tag 'description' for things like "Wyndham TV Transmission site", or 'operator' for "Coleman Transport".

I have increased the industrial area for "Wyndham TV Transmission site" to encompass the area that appears to be used.

The circular- buildings might be man_made=silo?

Hi,
Error on building way/1032746473. See https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=150.16585&lat=-33.48337&zoom=18
Leave you to fix it.

Hi,
This area is inside Victoria... ???

Hi,
Relation: Sydney Metro Northwest (8631621) error reported by OSMInspector - PTV2. Train route finish platform was placed at the end of the relation members. This has been corrected to the end of the platforms/stops .. The ways then follow those platforms/stops.

Hi,

When a footway crosses a building .. there is either an entrance - should be mapped as a node on both the footway and building, or the building is a roof and should be tagged layer=1 (or 1 higher than the footway layer).
Footway Way: 1031077605 crosses several buildings..

One of the 'problems' is that renders regard landuse=forest to be the same as natural=wood.

The Putty State Forest includes grass areas .. and residential areas ... these should not be excluded form it. Much like a National Park has tree areas, rock areas, grass areas.. all part of the National Park.

The mapper who added the large tree area is simply mapping trees - not the land use.

Hi,
Pedantic mode engaged...

Usually the dominate land cover is mapped, so if mostly trees then natural=wood, if mostly grass then landcover=grass (and the ridiculous landuse=grass so it renders).

If both grass and trees must be mapped then we get micro mapping .. So I have made an example change - see relation/13780764

Hi,

The Putty State Forest is not a land cover ... and should not be changed to match tree cover or any other land cover. The Putty State Forest is truly a 'land USE'.
Changeset partly reverted to restore Putty State Forest.

Hi,

The park way/142127344 crossed itself, I have corrected that using Bing imagery. I have also removed the connection between the park way and the adjacent road.

Note that my comments stated the past tense. I have already made corrections.

relation/13761878 was created in this changeset.
See relation/13761878/history - version 1 is the start and the mapper there is you.
I am not local to the area hence my comment to you so you are aware of the changes, so you can asses them from your local knowledge.

Hi,
The multipolygon relation/13761878 for the brownfield was not closed. Additionally it carried a tag for a fence. I have closed the relation. And removed the fence tag - there would be gates to get through so the fence would not be continuous.

Suggest - map the fences with separate gates. Then include them in a relation for the brown field - the relation only has tags for the brown field not fences nor gates.

Hi,
The 'Off Leash Dog' park... I have made some changes

tag dog=yes to dog=unleashed
see dog=*
tag name=Off Leash Dog to description=Off Leash Dog area
see osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only

Keep mapping! The bush does need it.

Hey, thanks for that ...
but osm clinic = 10 or more of doctors, nurses and associated staff. Clinics offer outpatient care, diagnosis, radiology, treatment, and sometimes urgent care

so amenity=doctors would be more appropriate. Now I've go to go back and check my clinic entries! Doh!

Hi,

The 'brownfield' 'Log Cabin Hotel' relation is in error... see https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=150.68261&lat=-33.74737&zoom=17

Clinic? Or doctors?
"Triage capabilities' .. my local doctor does that too .. when required.
Do you have a web link for them .. I could not see one.

Flat Products Medical Centre ... does not appear to be a hospital... I have removed that tag and left the name and building...