OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
135601006

Hi,
No need for a multipolygon as there are no inners and other than trees these share no common tags.
I have deleted the relation, combined what were the other ways into singular ways and tag those as trees. This keeps thing simple.

120304603

Hi,
The Way: 1055704283 and Way: 1055704284 you added as fire stations for 'Fire and Rescue' on the DCS base map are 'Rural Fire Service' .. And it looks like it is a RFB ..https://www.facebook.com/TumutRFS/

135570676

Hi
Way 963500214 is in error.
See https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=147.25781&lat=-42.79120&zoom=19&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&overlays=duplicate_node%2Csingle_node_in_way%2Cduplicate_segment%2Cway_in_multiple_rings%2Cintersection%2Cintersecting_segments%2Cring_not_closed%2Ctouching_rings%2Crole_should_be_inner%2Crole_should_be_outer%2Cinner_with_same_tags%2Cways%2Cduplicate_node%2Csingle_node_in_way%2Cduplicate_segment%2Cway_in_multiple_rings%2Cintersection%2Cintersecting_segments%2Cring_not_closed%2Ctouching_rings%2Crole_should_be_inner%2Crole_should_be_outer%2Cinner_with_same_tags%2Cways

As they are separate buildings they should have 2 separate ways in OSM.

122346312

Is it a current source of water?

122346312

Hi,

I'm rather confused by the multiple tags on this object.

A water well.

And a bubbler - projects a small jet of water upwards for drinking.

If it has both of these it may be better to separate them .. the well as a way and the bubbler as a node???

133607742

In that area of the world .. when it rains it all gets wet :) creeks, rivers, roads etc.

Looking at wetland=* there is not much that matches what happens out here. I have mapped and area in SA as wetland .. but with the tag intermittent=yes. I' use that tag here on any 'natural' water feature except a bore.

56709041

HI,

How is this church a 'monument'???

Some would claim all religious buildings are monuments...

If it is a church then it would have some religion associated with it.. Greek Orthodox?

135251849

Why not delete the relation yourself then? Deleting the outerway destroys the relation .. and that then throws up errors on the QA tools that I see.

So, repeating myself, I have deleted the relation...

133607742

A 'wetland' in OSM is usually wet .. this one would be seldom wet... I think it is a riverbank .. with the tag intermittent=yes.

135251849

Hi,

This is the second time you have removed the outer way from the relation/10406083 (highway=service)
I'll just delete the relation...

135299232

Hi.
The changest comment does not look like it relates to the actual changes?

I have split the building relation in to 2 relations as they look like 2 separate buildings that touch. A single multipolygon relation outer ways cannot share segments and that was a fault with the single relation.

133607742

Hi,

What the DCS Base Map shows is the river bank .... What the imagery shows is that the river is 'intermittent'. I don't think 'wetland' is what is here.

130144565

Between No 25 and 19 there looks to be access to nos 26 to 31, these may never be built? In imagery there is a start of a road between 19 and 25 .. This could be public.
The path as mapped intrudes on to both 19 and 25, possibly the path could be changed to not intrude? @ boroli thoughts?

130144565

I would think the property boundaries of the DCS Base Map (Six Maps for nonOSM use) would be reasonably definitive. However it is not clear to me who would be 'responsible' for land between the park and those street properties. Possibly local council. I would be reluctant to tag most of it as 'public' as that leads to people assuming they can walk through the 'little bit at the end' (the true private bit) when they should not.
However I await GreplusLy5525Buenavista response as it could be more detailed.

135058077

Hi,
It was tagged as building=yes, now it is tagged as landuse=religious.

Firstly landuse=religious is now tagged on the outer way encompassing the whole site - this is normal practice in OSM as everything inside that boundary is used to support a religion.
See
landuse=religious
and
way/1163625850

Secondly the thing is a building. So tagging it building=* is ground truth. I did a web search that suggest the building could be a 'gurdwara'? Checking on taginfo there are 7 of these used around the world. I would suggest building=gurdwara and then making an OSM wiki page for them. By making an OSM wiki page you increase the possibility of people using it.

135058077

Hi,

Welcome to OSM.

The relation/15740081, landuse=religious, ... does not make sense...

It has 2 ways .. both with the role 'inner' meaning they are inside an 'outer' and are excluded from the 'landuse=religious'...
What I have done -
On the outside way place the tags landuse=religious, religion=sikh and then deleted 3 relations ... all of them related to this area and its landuse. Ths keeps things simple.

I did retag the building as a church... but it might be better as a temple???

Use the OSM wiki to help in understanding things ... e.g. amenity=place_of_worship

124172295

Hi,
Source 'page could not be found' ???

way/220688912 - a sports pitch, you added sport = football ... AFL? Rugby? Soccer? Which 'football'?

134822140

No response - deleted.

118232553

Arr.. think I have it now - someone added some nodes? And at least moved them .. see
changeset/134960623

134960623

Hi,
way/459973943 crosses it self.

Needs to be fixed ... See way/459973943

I think you moved some nodes for this platform and that is causing this issue.