Nodes tagged natural=tree is the correct method unless its a large area
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/155989952

Why were 2 roads mapped at Banton Boulevard?
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/155860170

It doesn't connect
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/155934566

reverted

changeset/156163984

reverted

changeset/156163980

reverted

changeset/156163739

reverted

changeset/156163718

osm.wiki/Vandalism

Please don't move address nodes around.
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/156098551

Please follow OSM guidelines instead of external forum posts.
https://tgctours.proboards.com/post/808477/thread

Tagging for the renderer is not ok. osm.wiki/Tagging_for_the_renderer

I am well aware of your intent behind editing OSM and the related issues. osm.wiki/Problematic_mapping/golf

Feel free to leave comments publicly so others may respond.

On 2024-09-01 23:57:39 UTC Blixt99 wrote:

> I have played golf on this very course many times over the decades. Have you? Have you ever played golf? It is not correct to say that every green on the course is surrounded by fairway. The fairways typically run up to the front of the green. The green typically has a fringe area and maybe a light rough area surrounding, but definitely not fairway. The proper way to designate the green and fairway areas is shown in the Wiki here ---->leisure=golf_course
>
> Please notice in the example that there can be shared nodes where the green meets the fairway, but they are both areas. The fairway is NOT a line, it is an area and should be tagged as an area just as the green is. Also note in the example that a sand trap, for instance, can be located in a fairway area as an area and the fairway area has the outer relationship while also tagged as golf=fairway and the sand trap has the inner relationship while also being tagged as golf=green.
>
> Why does this mundane stuff even matter to you? All I ask is that you not make yourself the judge and jury and just follow the Wiki instructions.
>
> My main reason for imploring you to not keep reverting back to inaccurate designations is that I like to recreate all the golf courses I have played in my life in the 2K Games game known as PGA Tour 2K23 where the course designer built into the game needs Lidar elevation data from USGS and GPS data from OSM to recreate the holes accurately. All of the GPS data from OSM has to come from areas such as greens, sand traps, water hazards, tee boxes and fairways.
>
> So please do not keep changing fairways from areas to lines. Thanks.

Multipolygons are areas. osm.wiki/Area

Multipolygons are areas. osm.wiki/Area

Multipolygons are areas. osm.wiki/Area

Multipolygons are areas. osm.wiki/Area

Multipolygons are areas. osm.wiki/Area

Based on what?