MxxCon's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 146942467 | These buildings are incorrectly tagged. Please read building=terrace
|
|
| 146731875 | This edit has similar problem as the other one. You should not delete valid data from OSM unless you have a very good reason to do so!
|
|
| 146731559 | Why did you extract perfectly valid address information from buildings and put them into separate address nodes?!
Deleting building=house also seems wrong. It's perfectly valid information and you deleted it. You made OSM data worse. This is borderline vandalism..
|
|
| 146728731 | These look like semi-detached buildings or even apartments rather than terraced(row houses).
|
|
| 146718895 | In this edit you again hijacked an address node and converted it into a landuse tag.. That doesn't seem correct. Why not add all those other relevant tags to the landuse area itself?
|
|
| 146718359 | Hello.
|
|
| 146711013 | Hello.
|
|
| 146801823 | You could've easily updated this building's tags 🙂
|
|
| 146793320 | Here also _1 and _2 tags should not be used at all.
|
|
| 146781637 | Tagging with _1, _2, _# is deprecated and should not be used at all.
|
|
| 146768828 | Hello.
|
|
| 146765279 | Why did you delete incline tags from steps in this edit?
|
|
| 146765075 | All of these photos are rotated 90' and are pretty low resolution. 🫤
|
|
| 146500032 | Hello.
|
|
| 146664067 | I'm not sure about how accurate/up-to-date that map is.. I looked through a bunch of different zoning and development maps and charts on both, ZoLa and NYC Planning for that area going back as far as I could find docs and didn't see a single reference to these driveways by that name.
Looking at that map around my home neighborhood I found at least one street name that also does not exist. When I saw it in OSM, I walked over there and asked people who live in homes on that "street" if they knew anything about that name and they had no idea what I was talking about. All the homes there had address of the main street nearby. The point is, I'm not sure that "more data" coming from that map is "better data". I'd trust a more precise, narrower scope maps from NYC itself rather than a US-wide amalgamation map. |
|
| 146411298 | opening_hours= tag has a way to encoding opening hours only for specific months of the year opening_hours=* |
|
| 146664067 | Here's cyclomedia imagery from Oct 2023 https://www.geocoder.nyc/streetview.html?lnglat=-73.99630486965181,40.72855354804826 that doesn't show street name signs.
|
|
| 146692215 | You could upload your pictures to Mapillary and help update its database. :)
|
|
| 146692215 | Btw, if you are mapping while out and about, there's app called EveryDoor. It's for Android and iOS. It's specifically targeted at editing POIs. It supports all the same presets as iD and it has some nice QoL features like automatically format phone numbers, biz hours, websites, etc.
|
|
| 146677415 | If this biz is closed, it's better to use lifecycle prefixes, or simply delete biz-specific tags, but leave address info. Doing that allows for that address to still be searchable and preserves history of that osm object.
|