OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
139229344

I told you already what kind of data problems were in the revert changeset.

If you would've followed the proper guidelines, those problems would've been spotted BEFORE the corrupted data was imported into OSM!
But since you DID NOT follow the guidelines and imported a huge amount of corrupted data into OSM, it's not acceptable to leave it in the database to hopefully let you repair it, ESPECIALLY since you replied more than 2 WEEKS LATER.
Fix your data first, show it to the community that it's correct and only then consider importing it again.

138595808

It doesn't matter that you used Excel. This is still undisclosed data import and you must follow what's written in osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines

139229344

Are we doing edit wars now?!
This edit WILL be reverted in full again until you correct all the data problems!
Furthermore, your account will be forwarded to DWG, which can result in account blocks or outright ban.

138597728

phone numbers were in the wrong format or corrupted or mushed together.
websites were in the wrong format. without protocol or just completely wrong.
there were other tags with a ton of stuffed keywords... more like for seo rather than anything useful
many biz names were not normalized.

like wtf is this... produce=apples;fruit and tree nuts;peach;pear;raspberry;tree nut;herbs and spices;beef;beef cows;lamb;mutton;sheep;honey;chicken;eggs;turkeys;asparagus;cucumber;eggplant;lettuce;mushrooms;potato;squash;tomato
product=hay;honeybees;horses;agritourism

138595808

Well then, your checking was bad and it had too many problems.

139181905

What is the actual location and address of this business? On their website it says address is 228 East 51st Street, yet below a map shows 235 East 51st Street.
Is this a sports club or a sports store?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139181905

139115591

How did you spot William Court mistake?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139115591

139109710

Hello.
This edit will be reverted in full since according to OSM wiki definition suburb is a more accurate tag value for Brooklyn. This has been discussed multiple times in the local community. It would be great if you consulted there first before making such significant changes.

changeset/139195544

139080250

In iD if you go into Background Settings panel, and enable "Show Background Panel" checkbox, it'll show you the age of satellite imagery, if it's available, so you can better figure out which one is the most recent.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139080250

139079930

Hmm. For some reason when I was looking earlier at the vintage of imagery it told me that esri clarify was newer than bing. Now it shows otherwise. I do see the feature you are referring to in bing imagery, but i'm not sure if it's a covered up pool. Its perimeter looks too flat. I'd expect a fence or something else. To me it looks more like different paving on the ground. Maybe a volleyball court or a playground. But ultimately on the big G it is clearly visible as a pool. 😉👍
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139079930

139106130

Hello.
You added description "Still elevated" to a curb node. Could you please elaborate what did you mean by this?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139106130

139105108

Hello.
When adding tags, unless they are names or a couple of other exceptions, values must always be lower cased.
In this changeset you added colour= tag with values of "Blue", "Green", etc. Those are not valid values. They have to be lower cased. 👍
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139105108

139087380

Hello.
If I remember correctly, Lyft folks recently deleted this or similar way here because they have more recent imagery from drivers going to this parking lot.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139087380

139080250

Hello.
Similar to the previous edit, why did you map 1192625196 as a rectangle when on the satellite imagery it's oval shaped?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139080250

139079930

Hello.
Why did you map 1192623726 as a rectangle when it's clearly a round pool?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139079930

139041823

Looking at the nearby nodes, Gotham Pizza was already mapped. I also added the icecream store and changed this one to the yorkville convenience.

139062037

Ah, thanks for clarifying. 👍🙂

139065351

Please note that this edit was reverted in full because every single tag you added is an invalid OSM tag.

changeset/139066273

139062037

Hello.
For this basketball court you added hoops=1, but satellite imagery shows there are 2 hoops, one on each side of the court.
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139062037

139059714

Hello.
It looks like there are some tagging mismatches where you tagged crossing way as "crossing=marked", but its intersecting node as "crossing=traffic_signals".
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/139059714