awesome, thanks a ton!

I restored the road previously (sorry).

If you want to have the road deleted you can either repeat your edit or revert my changeset #107868600 in JOSM (I can also do that if you want)

Hmm I wonder if that's some kind of iD bug.
Unfortunately iD is not that well maintained these days

Oh I see that you did a second edit.

I meant that you deleted this address point: 8762379169

And merged it into this address point: 8762436479

as addr:housenumber=18;233 and addr:street=East Dover Street;South Elm Street

(your second changeset changed the housenumber back to 18, but kept the street)

I was wondering if node/8762379169 was wrong and should be really deleted and if node/8762436479 address assigned to two streets at the same time.

So the house has two addresses at two different streets?
Also South Elm Street seems to be quite far from the house.

Oh, got it! Sorry!
That makes perfect sense to get it deleted. Thanks for the on-site survey.

Hi,
it's fine if the road leads to private houses. We just mark it as access=private, no need to delete.

It seems appropriate would be destroyed:building=yes + destroyed:tourism=hostel

destroyed=*:

Hi,
we were discussing these changes on Discord https://discord.com/channels/413070382636072960/763192797775265864/861983954059395072

The access tags are used separately, but not grouped under one 'access' key.
I changed it in following changeset #107521267

Hi,
please don't delete existing driveways. Thanks

Hi Paparobzzi,
thanks for your edits. Just a small thing: the name tag on building is not for descriptive information but for the actual name e.g. Empire State Building. Also the patio and pool area does not look to me like a building, but more like leisure=outdoor_seating ?

Otherwise great work!

Hi,
sorry what is going on in this changeset? You changed parking lot to park and then made a service road cross (twice) a golf course building.

Great job!
Just don't forget that street names should not be abbreviated. e.g. Rd -> Road

Hi,
any reason for deleting golf course grounds area?

Hi ogrategames and thanks for your contribution.

I just have to correct you that this is not how we map roads/paths. The correct way is to draw a single line along the center of the paved area as you can already see at the parking area.

Second issue is that when mapping green and fairway areas those should not overlap. Please see this section in documentation: leisure=golf_course#Common_mapping_pitfalls

Thanks for the fixes!
Just this seems a bit off ;) way/945650594

Yeah.. we had extensive discussions about this on Slack. The outcome was that the landowners should contact devs of the app or map and ask them to use access=private/no tag. (some like Gaia already are). If we just adapt our mapping to the apps this will only encourage them to further ignore our tagging.

Having those roads/paths could help in emergency situations or just improve general sense of orientation. Plus there is already tons of stuff in OSM that is not always accessible for everyone... private houses, backyard swimming pools, military compounds.. It is always up to each person to respect warnings and restrictions in real world and not just go somewhere because navigation sent them there.

Hi,
those those type of trails or roads we can tag as access=private or access=no

Hi,
Sorry but this is not how we map roads. They are just single line along the centre of the area. Look around in the surrounding area where it will be more clear.
Best,
Mashin

Thanks for the reply!
If it is as you say a closed complex then I guess you are right and more appropriate would be highway=service (without undefined service=parking_lot_road tag).

So if I understood correctly these service roads don't have official name (as on a road sign), but every building in the complex has address 380 Hitchcock Rd?
Then the correct way is to create a node at the place where the building is and fill out the address there e.g.:
addr:housenumber=380
addr:street=Hitchcock Road
addr:unit=3D

addr=*