It's not needed to have address-only names, unless it has special styling. (eg 700 Nathan; Nathan 700, Seven Hundred Nathan, etc)

Ok, I think you two are thinking about different parts. Let me see....

Please don't add descriptive labels to `name=`. That's for actual proper names only. Use `description:zh=`.

What's wrong with this one? There's clearly something there.

1. Please don't cite random "online" source. `name=` is the common name in use by the public currently, not what you or someone or history think it should be.
2. This was considered an `old_name=` by previous discussions. Please raise this issue again.

Please don't add `ele=` to `=ridge`. This doesn't make sense.

1. Another example is Chek Lap Kok being included in Tung Chung

(Btw if you are using your own instance, you could adjust how it works)

1. This would be a problem on Nominatm. It should return the island's name when there is one, as it is important as an address. However that's not what they do, so I don't understand what's their logic. https://github.com/osm-search/Nominatim/issues/1746 But it would be exhaustive and redundant to add a `=town` to every `=island`. Here, the important "Lantau Island" isn't listed for addresses on it either. That needs to be fixed first. This might help contain Discovery Bay within it. Unfortunately, the situation is Lantau Island is splitted between 3 District Council districts. I need to check how to handle this.
2. The problem here is there is no `boundary=administrative` below `admin_level=6 `anywhere, which in reality isn't even used for addressing. But adding `place=town` around might not solve it. On the contrary. you might cause Peng Chau to be returned on Lantau Island around the triangle intersection with Discovery Bay and Mui Wo, if Tai Shui Hang is downgraded from `=village` ( it should probably be a `=hamlet`) Discovery Bay is already returned for Disneyland in Penny's Bay, and the north shore on the other side of the mountain. That's clearly wrong too.
3. You did say "towns on islands". I need to review the definition for major populated islands here.

Please understand that it is considered a `place=island`, not `=town`. relation/9279538

125896795,125899891,125899201,125899117,125897623,125897588,125897548,125897332,125896912,125896876,125896822,125896795,125896578,125896523,125895298,125895099,125895015,125894946,125894883,125894042,125893997,125893643

125896795.125899891.125899201.125899117.125897623.125897588.125897548.125897332.125896912.125896876.125896822.125896795.125896578.125896523.125895298.125895099.125895015.125894946.125894883.125894042.125893997.125893643

2. Please don't make up English names by transliteration or romanization from Cantonese. Use `name:yue-Latn=` for the latter.

`highway=mini_roundabout` is not valid here.

Hi can you please re-confirm what the roads are? They can't be `highway=passing_place`. https://osmlab.github.io/changeset-map/#126460774

Please don't move things wildly. Use different points..

Please create a new point for different features. Don't move things wildly. If names are wrong, correct them only, not removing the entire thing.

Please create a new point for other features.

Please don't use `=peak` if it's not a high point over the entire surrounding.

Please be careful not to move unrelated features onto `boundary=administrative`.