OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
128725785

Please don't delete the `building=hotel`. This is to be refactored into `building:part=hotel`.

128648541

Please don't remove the address. It will remain.

128468962

Please don't change `leisure=track` to `=cycleway`. They are different. The most you can argue for is West Kowloon Cultural District. Others are closed-looped circuits in parks for training and fun, not for travel.

128442857

Please don't move features wildly. They represent two different things. Change only the name if you have a problem with it.

128411323

Please don't remove `marking:*=`. This is being tested in osm.wiki/Proposed_features/separation#Symbolic_separation:_marking together with `separation:*=`. See osm.wiki/Proposed_features/separation#Tagging_on_roads,_lanes_and_other_ways for examples.

128398998

This is vandalism,. Please don't upload tests.

125934883

Moved to `old_name:yue-Latn`

127772630

You can use https://revert.osmz.ru/ next time. changeset/127773579

127706969

4. Someone even suggested it should be "Luk Ngau Peak". This shows there is no commonly used variation.

127706969

1. You are not allowed to decide directly from Wikipedia. This is copyright infringement
2. It has been marked with `{{Unreferenced}}`
3. They haven't clearly distinguish whether this is an actually used English name, or only Cantonese phonetics.

127638673

4. `addr:region=Hong Kong` is not correct either.

127638673

3. eg is south of Tin Shui Wai station TIn Sui Wai? Can be no, because they are covered in Hung Shui Kiu and Ping Shan OZP respectively. But postal address and common use might be yes. Same for Fung Ka Wai east of Tin Tsz Road.

127638748

This is obviously wrong when TKO is more than that.

127638673

1. `place=town` is an abstract concept that shouldn't have a defined area
2. New Town or OZP is for planning purpose only, and is copyrighted.
3. It is debatable whether they are `boundary=administartive`. Postal address is a different matter.

125934804

Moved to `name:yue-Latn=`

125931068

Moved to `name:yue-Latn=`

127503390

5. Please don't make up English name by transliteration or romanization. `name:*=` is for those in common use by the public. Use `old_name:yue-Latn`.

127506830

There's no `natural=pass`. In OSM. `=saddle` and `mountain_pass=yes` are distinguished clearly. The former is a low point compared to the surroundings on a mountain. The latter is the highest point of a road going through a mountain. There can be a mountain pass without saddle, and vice versa. They often do not coincident.

127503390

3. Please use more descriptive changeset comments, not repeating the same vague sentence
4. Please group similar changes into one changeset to be uploaded. This is excessive fragmentation flooding the feed.

127503390

1. Please don't cite random "online" source. `name=` is the common name in use by the public currently, not what you or someone or history think it should be.
2. This was considered an `old_name=` by previous discussions. Please raise this issue again.