Kovoschiz's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 141364627 | Please don't change towers on podiums from `building=` to `building:part=` . This is not the common practice locally, and is debatable as to their definition. |
|
| 141364390 | `*:housenumber=` is used for the street number, not building number. They are all 7 as the estate here.
|
|
| 127056535 | If the eatery occupies the entire area, and the area has no other identity or info of its own, having `amenity=` on the area is correct. Especially as they should be `indoor=area` which should have another feature or feature-attribute tag to describe it, not `=room`. |
|
| 140976876 | The deletion is for this project only. It is only deferred, not cancelled. |
|
| 133777105 | 1. There is still a left turn from Ma Sik Rd though?
|
|
| 141237928 | Please don't use `=*_link` when they connect to different classes of roads. Eg Oi King St is not `=primary`. |
|
| 141232421 | !. While separate `addr:housenumber=` points is more detailed, you can still keep the main address used on the area. This aligns with the common practice in HK.
|
|
| 141191539 | 0. Please split your uploads.
|
|
| 141155689 | This shouldn't be done for data topology reasons. Eg you would not move them from `building=` to `type=building` either. |
|
| 141109746 | 1. The issue of `=motorway_junction` on restricted lane change braided ramps is quite uncertain. I discussed with Apple or some company once before. It is desirable not to duplicate it, while in this case North Point on-slip needs to be considered too. Now I imagine some form of `destination:*=` on the point of diverging may help. But you have already added `junction:ref=` (regardless of whether this is the best solution), so the `=motorway_junction` isn't absolutely necessary.
|
|
| 141111892 | Please don't modify the entire building. That's what you have edited here. Create a new point inside. |
|
| 141088821 | The other one looks correct (I'm not using Telegram) |
|
| 141088821 | This is actually for the larger `boundary=administrative` it is naming. There is another item for this location. |
|
| 141052594 | Please at least add `bicycle=yes` back to them. And I find `*cn_=yes` more proper and informative. |
|
| 141053104 | You haven't fixed it. At most, there is a `route=hiking` . No `route=mtb` . |
|
| 141012327 | Your other edits changeset/141012355 and changeset/141012355 hasn't been adding them to it. |
|
| 140985684 | You could coordinate on Discord to let everyone to see, not that it is crowded. Or use the wiki page. osm.wiki/Hong_Kong/Transport/Routes#專營巴士_Franchised_buses |
|
| 140987678 | Eg changeset/140987678
|
|
| 140972043 | For completeness, `*cn_ref=` is valid when they belong to a `=node_network` |
|
| 140972043 | There is complain in changeset/140987678 |