OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
173974081

Please split these changesets. This is difficult to discuss.
1. Lung Yuet Rd `=primary` is considered for connecting Cornwall St, not Nam Cheong St
2. When a road ends at roundabouts, the `=roundabout` currently doesn't use its classification, but the intersected roads

173959623

1. Please don't add `man_made=pier` directly when it's not constructed yet. `landuse=construction` + `construction:man_made=` has already been added.
2. `=pier` is for perpendicular ones projecting into the sea, not the same as loose colloquial meaning of any ship-berthing facilities. `=quay` has been used, as how it's named.

173869155

Please don't add descriptive labels to `name=` , as it's for proper names themselves only. Use `description=` if needed.

172427346

Please don't edit `place=` and `name=` if you don't know them, and didn't read doucmentation. District Council districts are not `=suburb=` nor `=town` in HK.

173795074

That's here way/158183482

173795074

3. And the `name=` is wrong

173795074

For this matter, I don't know what you are drawing either. I can only think of the Tung Chung Line branch.

173795074

Please don't add canceled proposals to OSM. `proposed:railway=` is for those likely to be built, and should really be those being funded, only not started constructions yet. Add them to OpenHistoricalMap.

173662265

2. And actually don't use titles and terms as " Town Park in Tseung Kwan O"

173662265

2. "Tseung Kwan O Town Park" is a generic term for town parks in TKO. Eg it's previous named for HK Velodrome Park.

173662265

Please don't add such descriptor labels to `name=` , which is for proper names only. OSM is a digital geographical database, not a paper map. Applications can already distinguish them with lack of icons.

173575519

1. As I must have explained before, Kam Tin Bypass is for connecting Kam Tin Rd eastward, and bypassing Kam Tin center. There's no "symmetry" here
2. Again, it's promoted for Sai Sha Rd connecting with Sai Kung already being `=secondary`
3. Doesn't explain the `=primary`

173575519

Why is this promoted to `=primary` directly?

173613356

Please don't add online-only businsses (or fakes)

154467382

I won't accuse everyone adding historical names is the same person without more incriminating evidence. But `old_name=` as usual.

173430965

Your one time alone doesn't mean it won't be used, considered, or rediscovered again. Referenced by them, ok? osm.wiki/Why_can't_I_delete_this_trail%3F#What_should_I_do_instead?

173430965

Please don't delete it directly, as it may still be used in search & rescue. It should be changed to `abandoned:highway=`

173369347

Speed limit isn't the same as train speed. The latter is affected by headway, and timetabling. You should only use real speed limits, signposted or codified rules.

173264435

Well then the problem is you have deleted the upper level of Chater Garden, and casually snapped the MTR exit to the corner unrealistically. The `=tunnel` section is not represented by the `building=` , and it would be the 1st step to make it routable. If you don't have time, don't want to, or don't know what to do, leave it alone. Don't simply delete things, and flunk it.

173264435

Please don't merge different sections blindly. Eg some are `indoor=yes` to be distinguished from `covered=yes`