GanderPL's Comments
| Post | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Teaching AI to Understand OpenStreetMap Tags |
MCP, or Model Context Protocol, is a tool designed specifically for AI systems and developers building AI applications. It acts as a backend server that provides structured data access—like querying OpenStreetMap tagging schemas—without any user interface (UI). No UI InvolvedThis MCP server has zero graphical interface, web forms, or chat-like frontend; it’s pure API endpoints for programmatic use. AI agents “know” how to connect to it via standardized protocols to fetch, validate, or suggest OSM tags automatically. Everyday Users Can’t Use ItIf you only interact with AI through simple web forms (like asking questions on ChatGPT’s site), you won’t be able to use this at all—no buttons to click or prompts to type will work here. It’s not for casual chatting; only AIs or coders who integrate it into apps can leverage it. |
|
| Teaching AI to Understand OpenStreetMap Tags | An MCP based on a formal schema produces much better results than the classic approach of creating agents like “You are an OSM expert”. Handling edge cases will be one of the main themes for versions v4 and v5. This effectively requires designing a dedicated exception schema, because there is currently no schema that explains these nuances clearly and comprehensively. I treat this as an endless playground for self‑improvement: even if I never reach the “ideal” goal, I will learn a lot along the way – from evaluating whether the project makes sense at all, through gaining humility toward complex problems, to better understanding OSM edge cases and how to work with AI. The whole thing was originally created with another tool in mind: something that ingests spaghetti‑like text notes, voice notes, and photos, and still manages to extract something reasonably coherent from them, without blindly combining completely unrelated tags. |
|
| Building drawing tips, a perfect guide | I have some edits that require a lot of fiddling, but I believe there are easier ways. I’ll send you questions about that, I just need to record how I do it now so you know what I’m trying to achieve. Maybe you can give me a better recipe. |
|
| Better-osm-org for watchmans | That’s interesting what you did. Good job. Inspiring. |