We welcome you as a new mapper.
Thanks for your contribution to this project.
This changeset is reviewed by a Global Validator to check that the tasks have been mapped in accordance with the quality standards of HOTOSM.
We cannot expect from a new mapper that he/she delivers high-quality mappings from the start, so we offer some guidance.
Please pay attention to the next summarized issues. (see attached document with examples for more info)
-------------------------------------------------------------
Buildings ought to be mapped as 'building=yes' nothing else.
Issues found on your mappings

A: Inaccurate mapping.

C: Collected adjacent buildings and mapped it as 1 building.
E: Buildings not squared or rounded.

Explanation can be found in this document which might be helpful to strengthen your mapping skills
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit

Best regards and keep mapping!
Frans S
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177178891

We welcome you as a new mapper.
Thanks for your contribution to this project.
This changeset is reviewed by a Global Validator to check that the tasks have been mapped in accordance with the quality standards of HOTOSM.
We cannot expect from a new mapper that he/she delivers high-quality mappings from the start, so we offer some guidance.
Please pay attention to the next summarized issues. (see attached document with examples for more info)
-------------------------------------------------------------
Buildings ought to be mapped as 'building=yes' nothing else.
Issues found on your mappings

A: Inaccurate mapping.

C: Collected adjacent buildings and mapped it as 1 building.
E: Buildings not squared or rounded.

Explanation can be found in this document which might be helpful to strengthen your mapping skills
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit

Best regards and keep mapping!
Frans S
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177178891

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
You deleted many buildings mapped by another mapper in 2021 and mapped them from scratch. I understand why you did it, but it is against the rules. You ought to adjust buildings by disconnecting them from other buildings and adjust the to their footprint.

Here are buildings with a saddle-type roof. Due to the angle at which the imagery was taken, they appears to be a trapezoid. However, it has a rectangular shape. Map it as such.
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please use the default tagging for buildings. 'building = yes, nothing else, nothing more.
Best regards

Helo. Thanks for mapping.
Please do not connect nodes of buildings to other features like roads.
These are issues that need to be solved.
The Issue triangle should show these issues.
Best regards

Hello. thanks for mapping
Check this footage to see how a high building ought to be mapped.
https://youtu.be/Tpi-BTMVo1M?si=4NU6ZUMQ0k2Sk1h5
Best regards

Thank you for mapping. You have correctly identified the location of most objects and mapped. However, a few points need improvements.
C: Collected adjacent buildings and mapped it as 1 building.
E: Buildings not squared or rounded.
G: Included the shadow of the building.

Reminder: Please be sure to square all rectangular buildings with the Q key
Reviewed by a validator at random or as requested.
FYI. Please view this video about common new mappers mistakes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xs5wX592E1o&t=2s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltn1VOiq5_0
In this document, you will find some hints and tricks which might help to expand your mapping skills.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit
Best regards and keep mapping.
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/175203192

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please be more accurate when you join a mapping session next time.
Your mappings are rather oversized, not squared.
Quality prevails above quantity !
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.

You often included the shadow (thick black line) into a building. This is not a part of a building.
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Your mappings are rather accurate! But,
Please do not cluster multiple buildings when it is obvious that they are individual buildings.
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please map more accurate. Don't include the shadow of a building and map the extensions on a building as well.
Best regards

Please check this footage where you can see which adjustments I had to make. (just a couple as an example)
https://overpass-api.de/achavi/?changeset=177303428
Please strengthen your mapping skills.
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177301099

Thanks for your contribution to this project.
This changeset is reviewed by a Global Validator to check that the tasks have been mapped in accordance with the quality standards of HOTOSM.

Please pay attention to the next summarized issues. (see attached document with examples for more info)
-------------------------------------------------------------

Issues found on your mappings

A: Inaccurate mapping.
C: Collected adjacent buildings and mapped it as 1 building.

E: Buildings not squared or rounded.
G: Included the shadow of the building.

Explanation can be found in this document which might be helpful to strengthen your mapping skills
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit

Best regards and keep mapping!
Frans S
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177301099

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please don't forget to square each building you map !
28 out of 192.
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Accurately mapped. However, be sure all buildings are squared.
Best regards.

Hi.
Don't you use the building plugin?
Very helpful to draw correct rectangular buildings.
Check this please

osm.wiki/JOSM/Plugins/BuildingsTools
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
I am reviewing your mappings and am sorry to say that your mapping skills are not sufficient to map to map on these complex building situations.
Even high experienced mappers have difficulty accurately representing the buildings here.
The combination of Hi-rise buildings , lower building blocks, and lower buildings makes it difficult.
Check here how hi-rise buildings ought to be mapped.

https://youtu.be/dsfUcslLtVc?si=yH6eWDbsb_ILAVb9
Please select easier tasks or projects to map. We (validators) have a lot of work to adjust your mappings on this project.
Best regards and keep mapping

i again. The image on Esri looks different as the one on Bing.
When you take a look on Google Earth, it is similar as Bing.
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping on this project.
It a challenge to map high rise buildings correctly. They have a different appoach.
Map over the roofline and move the whole to its footprint.
Check this footage please.
You might change the imagery as well. Esri world shows also a better view.
When you mapped a high building correctly, the mapping appeared on both images on the footprint.(correct offset where needed)
Check this footage please
https://youtu.be/dsfUcslLtVc?si=yH6eWDbsb_ILAVb9
Best regards

Hello. Back again.
You clustered numerous buildings.
Each building needs to be mapped individually.
Best regards.