Hello. thanks for mapping.
Are you aware that you duplicated 112 buildings in this area ? Mainly task 553 and 1551
I removed the duplicated ones.
Never considered changing to JOSM ?
Given the quantity of mappings you deliver, it might be worth it to change.
best regards

Thanks for mapping. Accurately mapped.
Just a remark on this mapping
way/1474094177/history#map=19/12.105208/15.122364
You mapped both a building. tree and courtyard as 1 building. Check the Mapbox imagery to see what I mean.
I adjusted it.
Best regards and keep mapping

Thank you for bringing this issue to my attention.
I consulted the wiki
osm.wiki/Indonesian_Tagging_Guidelines#Roads
.
While validating tasks, I regularly came across highways tagged as living_street.
Considering that a ‘living_street’ is generally (from my Western perspective) a road that is specifically designed for pedestrian traffic and local residents, where cars/motorcycles, etc. are banned as much as possible. So I retagged them to
residential highway when I also took the width of such a road into consideration.
I regularly come across incorrectly tagged roads, which I often change to what I consider to be a better tag.
Think of tracks connecting settlements, residential highways in rural areas, paths wide enough to be an unclassified road, etc.
I also see places where a road has been retagged to ‘living street’, when it is actually a connecting road >2.5 meters or more or runs through rural areas. I usually adjust these.

I have changed most (hundreds) of the taggings I changed to residential highways back to ‘living_street’.
It is impossible to name specific locations, because I have validated almost 1300 tasks. An impossible task.
I hope this has provided you with sufficient information.
Kind regards

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)

Hello. Thanks for mapping on this task.
PLease check this footage how to map high buildings.

https://youtu.be/u31wPYWkm3E?si=lDbvDutpUyZWQXXL

Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
You mapped high-rise buildings incorrectly.
Check this footage on how to map them correctly.

https://youtu.be/Tpi-BTMVo1M?si=LCu1gM_lmESjveU0
Best regards

Check this footage of how to map highrise buildings

https://youtu.be/Tpi-BTMVo1M?si=LCu1gM_lmESjveU0

Best regards
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177875931

Thank you for mapping. You have correctly identified the location of most objects and mapped.
However, High rise / buildings with a few storys needs a different approach. See the link to the footage I've send you.

Reminder: Please be sure to square all rectangular buildings with the Q key
Reviewed by a validator at random or as requested.
FYI. Please view this video about common new mappers mistakes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xs5wX592E1o&t=2s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltn1VOiq5_0
In this document, you will find some hints and tricks which might help to expand your mapping skills.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit
Best regards and keep mapping.
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/177879200

We welcome you as a new mapper.
Thanks for your contribution to this project.
This changeset is reviewed by a Global Validator to check that the tasks have been mapped in accordance with the quality standards of HOTOSM.
We cannot expect from a new mapper that he/she delivers high-quality mappings from the start, so we offer some guidance.
Please pay attention to the next summarized issues. (see attached document with examples for more info)
-------------------------------------------------------------
Issues found on your mappings

A: Inaccurate mapping.

B: Overlapping buildings.

C: Collected adjacent buildings and mapped it as 1 building.
D: Connecting nodes to other features.

High building(s) incorrectly mapped.
Check this footage on how to map high buildings: https://youtu.be/dsfUcslLtVc?si=yH6eWDbsb_ILAVb9
Or see par. 20, chapter About Buildings.

Explanation can be found in this document which might be helpful to strengthen your mapping skills
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Swwz-ZwM3_YOstqstsmCg1-lNAPbnMLpi1Al-h-2UOQ/edit

Best regards and keep mapping!
Frans S

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Why do you tag a minor road, going into and ends in a wooded area as a secundary road?
Please check your knowledge of how to tag roads.
Best regards

Hello.
I reviewed this task to check that the task is correct validated.
A few remarks here.
You did not retag wrongly tagged buildings. Landuse=residential. should be tagged as building =yes
Piece of highway (rather wide) was tagged as path. It should be tagged as unclassified.
This are issues which has to be found and corrected by a validator !
Frans S
Global validater.

A new mapper. Welcome.
Your work is reviewed by a global validator.
In general. Precise mapped.
Some errors made.
Never connect nodes of buildings to other features.
Why add layers to a building? Avoid errors? This is not a solution.. Just adjust the mapping of the building or road.
And, square each rectangular building, please.

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Tag buildings as 'building=yes' This is default for HOTOSM projects.
You cannot decide from a satellite image what the purpose is of a building. Leave that to local mappers.

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Why do you tag objects which are good to identify als buildings as 'natural=water' ?
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
This is a building and highway project.
A number of throughgoing roads are tagged as track in the past despite the fact that they should be tagged as "tertiary".
Please check those roads as well and retag them where it is obvious.
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please do not connect nodes of (service) roads to a building or other features except roads. These are errors that have to be adjusted.
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
A remark.
When you map a road that continues over the edge of your task, please draw it a bit over the edge. Now you stopped before the edge. Another mapper, working on the adjacent task will not see it. when you draw it a bit over the edge, he can continue.
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please do not tag highways in rural areas as a residential road, Unclassified is a better choice.
Best regards

Hello.
A remark.
You are mapping on JOSM.
Are you familiar with the plugin
Data Validator
and map paint style : inline validations ?
These are very usefull tools and assist you to review your mappings and correct issues before you upload your work.
Best regards

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
An important issue.
When you draw highways/paths and come across other roads, please connect them to eachother to achieve a network where you can navigate with NAV systems. When a road ends or the nodes are not connected to other roads, the NAV systems won't work further.
(this is also the case when nodes of a road are connected to buildings ,landuse areas etc.
Best regards and keep mapping

Hello. Thanks for mapping.
Please try to decide how to tag the traces of roads/paths, Wider than 2,5 mtr =unclassified + unpaved, narrower tag it as a path.
Use the Bing imagery for a better view, but align the roads with the project imagery please.
Best regards and