OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
127699211

Hi
Please don't add nodes for entities which already exist as ways.

In fact, as existing data can't be viewed, the best advice is on the Maps.me wiki: "Don't use Maps.me for editing OpenStreetMap data."

way/120948596/history

145442945

Hi
There are now three entities representing Gravesend Life boat Station. Two added by you.

I note the boats are moored on the pier's pontoons, but do you know where the actual office build is located?

97562169

Hi
node/8283039160/history

Where did you get the information for this boat's location?

Is there a reason it's not moored at the dock?

145342087

Hi
Because they're two buildings for the same Morecambe Lifeboat Station.
https://rnli.org/find-my-nearest/lifeboat-stations/morecambe-lifeboat-station

Discussion about my proposed edits (continues into Dec):
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-gb/2023-November/030914.html

145076196

OK.
Could you reinstate it please.

145107110

Hi
The building doesn't look like that; there's a roof over.

145076196

Hi
Is there a reason you deleted the landuse=railway polygon?

144629567

Hi

Did either of you partake in the discussion (I don't recognise your user names) or were you just out to finger-wag?

144978340

Hi
Could you please remember to add the area tags to polygon platforms.

144994799

Hi
Please don't do that.

142142907

Hi
Please refrain from adding duplicate railway=station tags. There should only be one per station.

node/11238169295

141584968

Hi
Please don't duplicate railway=station tags. There should only be one per station.

node/3704548353

144702876

Hi
Similarly with this one:
node/694365541

144702876

Hi
You appear to have move this pus stop from it's correct position & attached it to a residential polygon.

node/694365545#map=19/51.37334/-2.36602

144629567

I believe there was more than one. I didn't partake in those to discuss the deprecation of various tags into emergency=water_rescue, but that's what's happened. That's what this changeset implements.

Talk-GB & Talk-ie (if my post has been authorised yet) contains an ongoing discussion in how to ensure there's the correct number of objects to correspond with the RNLI database & other independent rescue services.

PS Just because a discussion wasn't declared it's /not/ "reasonable to assume that this mechanical edit wasn't discussed."

144629567

Why do you think it's not discussed?

144629038

Reverting this changeset

144505446

Please don't delete area tags from platforms, They're required due to a bug in OSM-Carto

144342090

I've emailed Cots wolds to ask for confirmation.

144342090

Could you post a link that shows how it's changed?