Hi! Is there a no-bicycle sign there? Usually, it is permitted to ride a bicycle on any street except motorways or streets with a specific no-bicycle sign.

This changeset delete footways and thus will break routing in this area. I have to revert this. Can you explain why you deleted footways? Footway areas are ok to use, but you need to keep the highway footways as no routing engine can route on areas.

Sorry this was the incorrect changest for the deletion: see changeset/150462594 instead

This changeset delete footways and thus will break routing in this area. I have to revert this. Can you explain why you deleted footways? Footway areas are ok to use, but you need to keep the highway footways as no routing engine can route on areas.

Why a node in Quebec was changed in this changeset?

You can keep the entrance tag also, since it describes the door itself

Please use railway=train_station_entrance
instead of subway_entrance, which is only for subway networks.

Hi! some of your edits in this area removed the placement=transition tags which were carefully added for precision. All the motorways in the Montreal area have been carefully aligned using theorical and physical gores, as well as transitions between number of lanes. Please keep them as they were. Thanks!

Hi!

Thanks fo your edits around Châteauguay!

Can you make sure not to add duplicates for shops and POIs? the tags you added on buildings were already on the nodes that were layered on top of the buildings. In the Quebec area, we usually map POIs as nodes instead of on the building, because most buildings can have multiple POIs inside them and it is easier to maintain that way. Also, OSM wiki says that we must not add the tags to both the buiding and the nodes. When doing so, search engines will return two POIs for the same query. Thanks!

Attention aux lanes:forward=2 sur une route à deux voies bidirectionnelle. lanes:forward=2 veut dire deux voies dans la même direction: exemple si lanes=4 et lanes:forward=2 et lanes:backward=2, ça veut dire 2 voies dans chaque direction. Ici il n'y a qu'une voie par direction, donc laisser lanes=2 et retirer lanes:forward (par défaut lanes:forward=2 et lanes:backward=1)

Your description is correct, but you changed the street at another place where it is two-way. I fixed it.

Hi!
Would it be possible to update the swimming pools with the tag: access=private ?
By default, the access is yes, so anyone can access.
Thanks!

Nice! Thanks

A parking lane could be considered a barrier. We'll wait for up to date aerial imagery before realigning it, so for now your work is good :-) Thanks!

And it is bidirectional?

Hi! Thanks for updating data!

Can you confirm that this cycling track is separated from the road with a barrier or concrete curb? If it isn't, we usually add the cycling tags to the road itself (cycleway:right=lane with other associated tags). Thanks!

OK, so following this guide, it seems legit. It should be added to the official wiki though, otherwise people will keep merging the segments.

Adding street names to sidewalks is quite essential nowadays, because routing engines use them instead of the street themselves, and without any names on sidewalks, you would get very obscure routing because the complete set of directions would never give you any street name, which would be bad. In Quebec province, I have never seen anyone having problems with this, so I guess it is ok for us.

Thanks!

Please do not create small segments of sidewalk at intersections, because we cannot name these to the correct street name (they are a connection for two streets). Where did you see examples of these in the wiki?

Also, please use this offset when editing precise data in the Montreal area using the Bing 2020 imagery:
0.6, -1.54
as explained here: osm.wiki/Montr%C3%A9al under Bing Maps offset

Thanks!

Thanks for editing this park. However, please do not connect landuse with roads, since it makes it very difficult to edit roads and add sidewalks and footpaths then, since everything is connected. I fixed it in changeset changeset/147565946