Aleksandar Matejevic's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 137529391 | Thanks for the fast reply. Will you make the change or should I do it? |
|
| 137529391 | Hi,
|
|
| 139303983 | Hi Lucas,
|
|
| 140496487 | Hi, you have created a lot of duplicated geometries of roads. Can you recheck and fix this |
|
| 140315865 | Thanks for the info. I have checked Bing; Mapbox Satellite; Esri World Imagery (Clarity) Beta; Esri World Imagery and I am confident that these roads exist. Is there any issue or this is just info about Bing imagery? It shows that images were captured between 1/17/2014-10/29/2021 but on the north imagery is from before 2003. |
|
| 139632988 | For the example I have mentioned, there are 2 tags that you have removed:
I think I can see where the issue is: Working in ID editor, you can not change the name, so you need to delete these 2 tags so you can enable editing of the name. Please do not do that, just expand Tags and then correct the tag you need, in that way you will not remove Wikipedia and Wikidata tags |
|
| 139632988 | Hi Rigel Ricardo Valladares Mendez, can you tell me why have you removed a lot of Wikipedia an wikidata tags in this and some other changesets? For example node/2424436670 |
|
| 139993537 | I have found out that you have removed Wikipedia links in New Zealand also, even if they were in English, the official language, so please do not remove Wikipedia tags, they are here for a reason, if you want you can replace the English version with the local language version, but if there is no local version, leave English or whatever one is added. |
|
| 139946204 | Can you be more specific? I have removed coastline tag because it was wringly used. Please read this osm.wiki/Coastline |
|
| 139993537 | Hi StenSoft,
|
|
| 139799982 | Hi Phil,
|
|
| 139799982 | I was not using Wiki, I have been using OS OpenMap Local, Mapillary, and what is already with the operator tag of the University of Leicester. I will go over their website to check what is wrong. |
|
| 139796217 | Sure, will do, just to add some more relations if that is not a problem. |
|
| 139832345 | Hi Phil,
The community was against changing current tagging since many universities are using OSM for their website maps. There are some examples across the globe proposed, but the final was do not change already tagged entities. No one objected to the idea of creating type=site relations since for some universities, you will find a lot of buildings, land, and accommodation operated by a certain university, and they are not of the same type. The main thing for creating these relations is to make these universities visible and easily searchable on OSM. The operator tag is not searchable in the current search box, you will need to have overpass knowledge for this, and even then you will not have all things in one place. This was the first thing done, adding an operator tag based on the uni website, but it turned out to be a time-consuming job, a lot of things were not tagged, and if someone removes the tag, you will not have a result in a query. A lot of unexperienced mappers delete tags on ID editor, but if you have a relation, that is way difficult to remove so it gives the extra safety that the university will be found at the end. Another thing is that you can put variant names on just one relation and that will cover the search in different languages. Germany has a lot of relations to fix similar issues. After creating the relation I would like to improve geometries, one by one University at the time, add variant names and probably create a MapRoullete task across other communities to name them on their languages. Also, there is a tagging schema that is still under proposal, but I do not see that it will not be approved and then it will be way easier to add just member type and everything will be in line. But yes, it was discussed on Loomio and talk-gb, also some emails were exchanged with OSMUK board. I have also received some positive feedback for some users, but I also appreciate your concern. |
|
| 139535414 | Hi WyoGuy2,
|
|
| 139549836 | Please, be careful while editing, you have deleted a couple of relations. |
|
| 137372010 | Hi Amiri,
|
|
| 137049655 | Thanks wireguy,
|
|
| 137217449 | Hi Berete Baba,
|
|
| 136472096 | Can you please fix relation/15898754 - Mesopotamia Township
|