This appears to have a typo in seamark:light:character where you have swapped in a capital letter I for the lower case L in "Fl" for "flash". I have changed them all to the F L value but let me know if you meant something else!

Hello I would love to chat with out about some style adjustments that will make your map data more useful and resilient.

I left a comment here: changeset/176686512

I am worried that someone will simply have to remove your hard work at some point and start over. Which I think we both agree is not ideal! :-D

And because of diligent mappers we know of at least 2 schools that do have horse-man hybrids for a mascot!

https://overpass-turbo.eu/?w=%22mascot%22%3D%22Centaurs%22+global&R

Hello Deven!

Thanks for contributing. As a point of practice, it's greatly preferable to create smaller individual features with their own tags. This area being a collection of a few enormous multi-polygons makes ongoing maintenance a huge bother.

I know iD makes is easy to generate these monsters but they really are a huge source of pain down the line. Much better to keep is simple. Break features up. Don't include everything together in out object just because it will have the same tag (the wetland here could be lots of small pieces for example). If you have to have an outer and with an inner cut out of it it's best for the outers and inners to be complete rings in their own right etc.

Anyhow, the geometry and work looks really good! my only feedback is about the representation.

Happy mapping!

Matt

It's always fun to find these. Easy to clean up. Thanks for reminding me of it again. I always get a chuckle out of it.

Happy mapping!

Hello! Small error I think... The U-2 here should use Q189064 for the spy plane not the submarine.

Thanks for getting things added! Happy mapping.

I am updating population tags and I stumbled into this edit setting the population to 1. Which is very amusing.

You have a series of edits to this node that keep pushing the tagged population date further and further back. Any idea what you actually meant to do?

The population tag should reflect a reasonable current population.

Hello! I would be great to add some more detail in your changeset messages than "updates".

More info here: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

Oh that's funny. I was just starting to look at population tag stuff and how to get things tidied up.

The population here is marked as "2" I presume this is an accidental truncation of "2,960" which is from the 2020 census (or similar).

Easy to fix up but I figured I would mention it. :-D

I love a giant circle so there are a bit of a pet feature of mine. Plus all the pac-man ones!

Hello! Thanks for all the additions.

I can probably save you some time. The farmland for these pivot irritation fields can be drawn as full circles and don't need the cutout for the track road. Honestly, The path into the center seems to move around on various imagery... I'm not saying don't add it but it's not a super stable feature.

At any rate, feel free to add irrication=pivot if you want to add a bit of tagging depth to these.

Happy mapping!

This has been opened with DWG as Ticket#2026011610000455.

You don't need any particular email provider to join. Anyone can join from this link. https://slack.openstreetmap.us/

Hello. I have stumbled upon this set of edits and agree it should be reverted. Name fields in the US include directional and types when they are know (signed or from address data etc). If you have a rendered or app that you'd like to not see those in, well, ask the owner of that to eliminate them in their pipeline.

As it's been a few months and the changes are broad, I am going to ask the dwg to do this reversion.

In the future, I suggest you work the broader community before making such sweeping edits. It will save you some time and keep things rolling more smoothly.

It's super weird. I must not have had both geometries downloaded into the layer. So one got simplified and the the other didn't but because they were somewhat gradually shifting, I missed it as I did my manual scroll through. I have patched that spot up. Good catch.

Can you tell me about your overlap checks? I would love to know more.

Oh goodness. Let me review this and the couple of my other recent changesets like this. I am a bit surprised this did trigger a JOSM warning but will investigate that too.

Thanks for pointing it out!

May we all have a mappy new year! Wooo 2026!!

thanks for adding this and tagging it with sport=jetsprint. It's a bit fiddly to get it exactly right in the web editor so I have made some small adjustments.

I love these weird little lakes! https://en.osm.town/@watmildon/113207012226449177