btw: i was talking about landuse areas - not boundaries. Boundaries still have to be mapped as MP

may be in Josm F for follow may help. it will jump from node to node. this makes it easier to draw ways using existing nodes of the "neighbours"
and the other is to use ALTG GR to select overlapping ways.

may be that helps.

oops, using french josm! may be, you dont't live there. Sorry, did not see that.

Hi Ivan, thanks for enhancing your country. good work :)

one comment on creating multipolygons: there is a trend in osm to avoid simple multipolygons whenever that is possible.
MP should only be created when they contain outer or inner. The rest should be mapped as simple closed ways. yes, they do overlap, but that is much easier to handle instead of MP containing many ways.

i'm trying to find a wiki doc, but can't find it just now.

regards, walter

btw. don't be too angry because of the Srpska trouble last week.

That is no must but may be you try it. it's faster and easier for most of the mappers, which are not experienced in using MP.

Hi EzekielT. no easy stuff ;)
see https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?pid=675929#p675929

please read this answer at the forum:

#######################

Just for clarification:

There is a 'Kingdom of the Netherlands' (plural intended) - or 'Koninkrijk der Nederlanden' (idem).
Within this kingdom there are 4 autonomous countries:
- the Netherlands (again, plural intended in English), but 'Nederland' (no plural) in Dutch - and note: without 'kingdom' here;
- Curacao;
- Aruba;
- St. Maarten.
Each of these 4 above have full authority over everything apart from defense and representation at the UN - these 2 are done by the Netherlands / Nederland for all 4.
The latter 3 are former parts of the Netherlands Antilles, an administrative unit that no longer exists.
The other parts of the former Netherlands Antilles, the islands of Bonaire, Saba and St. Eustatius, are 'special administrative units', sort of special counties, within the Netherlands / Nederland.

The issue mentioned above is that Curacao is treated with postal codes from the Netherlands / Nederland, which is indeed incorrect.

So there is a 'Kingdom of the Netherlands' (covering 4 countries) and a 'the Netherlands' (being one country within aforementioned kingdom).

I hope this clarifies rather than confuses ;-)

Marcel
(I spend some 3 days on a conference about 8, 9 years ago explaining this to an ISO commission who dealt with this sort of geo-chaos, including UK crown colonies, FR special overseas departments, special autonomous regions ... etc.). I know first-hand it's hard.
#######################
link to forum: https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?pid=675685#p675685

@michal i tried to revert his changes, may be i missed that?

Hi Ivan,

beside the fact, that this was a political motivated edit (Rep Srpska is NOT an internationally recognised country), you made some technical errors.

changes have been reverted.

cs: changeset/53853453

Hi Susana,

something is going completely wrong. Those place areas are NO MEMBERS of the El Libertador relation. They are only simple closed lines.

i had to fix a lot of those dubious "constructions" in Argentina during the last weeks. Please stop that.

If you got questions, please contact me.

Regards
walter, Germany

Hi, hast du das immer noch nicht verstanden, wie das Löschen funktioniert?

du machst immer noch den gleichen fehler und ich muss dir dann hinterherputzen :(

abgesehen davon, dass das Löschen an sich schon nicht ok ist, weiol man Relationen ändern soll und nicht einfach neue rels erzeugt. damit wird die History gelöscht und das wird bei OSM überhaupt nicht gerne gesehen.

werde wohl bald mal mit der DWG sprechen müssen.

that is NO building, that is an AREA

nö, wohl nicht. so wie ich das sehe, löscht du die Member der Relation aber nicht die Relation selber. Klick mal auf die Papiertonne UNTERHALB des Rel-Fensters. DAS löscht Relationen ;)

indem man die relation löscht ;) geht in josm ganz einfach rechts im relationen-fenster

und wenn du wirklich die neuen rels erzeugen musst: warum löscht du dann nicht die alten?

Ich bin wegen "Diverses" bereits gesperrt worden. Also sei bitte etwas konkreter.

aber wichtiger: was ist mit den leeren Grenzrelationen? Warum erzeugst du neue Relationen und nimmst nicht einfach die bestehenden?

walter

still doing the same????

did not read my mail? please use better cs comments. WIP is not ok.

no "living streets"

wrong: that are nor oneways
not residential (nobody living there) but highway=service