tekim's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 109470125 | Looks like vandalism. Can someone revert? |
|
| 109459387 | How does one determine the name of a building from "Bing aerial imagery." Please cite your sources with your changesets.
|
|
| 109459518 | You added a name with only "Bing aerial imagery" as a source. How does one determine the name of a road for overhead imagery?
|
|
| 109462486 | What is the source for your changes? You only cite "Bing aerial imagery" but you changed a name, and added address information - none of which is likely to be gleaned from "Bing aerial imagery"
|
|
| 109175968 | Thanks for responding to my comments. 1) Don't guess when editing OSM. 2) When you make a change, cite your specific source with the changeset. |
|
| 109432176 | Sources cited do not support changes made. No way to determine maxspeed=* from "Bing aerial imagery"
|
|
| 109431450 | Sources cited do not support all of the changes made. For example, generally not possible to determine bicycle=* based on "Bing aerial imagery"
|
|
| 109431112 | sources cited do not support all of the changes made. For example, no way to determine bicycle=yes from "Mapbox Satellite;Bing aerial imagery;Esri World Imagery (Clarity) Beta"
|
|
| 109428544 | sources cited do not support all of the changes made. How can you get "bicycle:conditional=dismount @ (Mo-Fr 07:30-17:00)" from "Bing aerial imagery;Esri World Imagery;Mapbox Satellite"
|
|
| 109427999 | sources cited do not support all of the changes made. How can you get maxspeed=25 mph from "Bing aerial imagery;Mapbox Satellite;Esri World Imagery"?
|
|
| 109424594 | Sources cited do not support all of the changes made. What is the source for motor_vehicle=private onhttps://www.openstreetmap.org/way/971723603
|
|
| 109424939 | Sources cited do not support all of the changes made
|
|
| 109425724 | sources cited do not support all of the changes made
|
|
| 108638121 | If the road provides access to multiple houses, it should be highway=residential. That is the correct class - the road is very important to the families that live along it. BTW, most of what you are mapping in this area isn't really National Forest per se, it is private land. Mapbox - like anyone else - is free to map anywhere they would like, but if your objective is to map "protected areas", this doesn't really qualify. |
|
| 109367705 | This is another changeset where the cited sources (Bing aerial imagery;Esri World Imagery;Esri World Imagery (Clarity) Beta;Mapbox Satellite), do not support all of the changes made, e.g. how do you know from those sources that access=permissive? Your changeset needs to cite the sources actually used. |
|
| 109350928 | It would be very helpful if you could restrict the geographic extent of your changesets to a reasonable size, such as that of a small city. |
|
| 109328855 | The source cited "Bing aerial imagery" does not support all of the changes being made in the changeset, for example, there is no way to tell for sure from "Bing aerial imagery" that way/781963882 is surface=wood. It could be composite decking for example. |
|
| 109324688 | The sources cited do not support all of the changes made, for example one can not deduce from "Bing aerial imagery;Esri World Imagery;Mapbox Satellite" that maxspeed=20 for way/164014396 |
|
| 109329363 | This is another changeset that where the source cited "Bing aerial imagery" does not support all of the changes made, such as bicycle=yes
|
|
| 109331300 | This is another changeset where the cited sources (Bing aerial imagery;Esri World Imagery) do not support all of the changes made, for example maxspeed=*
|