The nodes and ways are actually still in the database but marked as visible=no (in the user interface, they are labeled as "deleted" but they are not actually deleted).

Once the other construction phases have been started, we can then "undelete" them. The advantage of this is that these ways do not interfere with existing data and newbies using iD do not accidentally connect other stuff like buildings and POIs to these proposed roads.

AFAIK, only the very northern part of the subway (~3 stations from Mindanao Avenue) is actually *currently* being constructed. So it is incorrect to state that the *whole* line is already under construction.

It is not an widely established practice, but many mappers use the admin_level=* tag to represent what level of government a particular feature applies to such as government offices and not only for boundaries.

Here's an example of a traffic sign that uses admin_level=6:
node/5138691464

Great! Thanks!

Correction: should be gns_uni=*, not gns_unit=*

Hi JAT86,

Is there any particular reason why you restored/added the gns_classification=* tag? Unless the node also has the gns_unit=* tag, this tag is useless for data-matching purposes. Also the gns_*=* tags are not documented in the OSM Wiki and were a remnant of place name imports done in the past.

In addition, referring back to the GEOnet Names Server (GNS) is not particularly useful for OSM's purposes. GNS is useful as a source of data but not something that should be relied on as stated by the list of caveats on the OSM Wiki: osm.wiki/GEOnet_Names_Server#Caveats

It would actually be more useful to link the place=town nodes to their corresponding Wikidata items using wikidata=* and maybe also tag them with ref=* using their PSGC id.

@GOwin, I see that this changeset is over 4 years old, but is there any reason why you deleted node/945582522 which is the place=suburb node for Betis, Guagua? Betis is a significant district of Guagua anchored by Betis Church, a designated National Cultural Treasure. Note that Betis is not a barangay on its own. (Looking back at it, not sure though if place=quarter may be more appropriate than place=suburb.)

Why are you adding name:it tags to points of interest that do not really have Italian names?

The building is already correctly named as "Burgundy Corporate Tower". What you have done is to rename a school inside the building incorrectly.

Hi! The correct tag for the Aquabest POI that you added is shop=water.

You removed the building=* tag but you forgot to building:levels=* tag.

Hi!

Thank you for your contributions to OpenStreetMap!

May I confirm what type of businesses you have added? You have marked them as tourism=artwork which is for sculptures, murals, and other pieces of public art, and not for printing services.

Hi!

Thank you for your contributions to OpenStreetMap!

May I confirm that this edit where you deleted a path is correct? I believe this path is for the pedestrian underpass going under Makati Avenue. Does this underpass no longer exist?

If the highway is not actually *currently* being constructed (or is still in the proposed state), marking it as highway=construction is not appropriate.

Even then, only the sections that are being constructed should be marked as highway=construction and not the whole highway.

OK. This node's position now looks really weird:
node/734948145

What imagery offset did you use for Bing?

@GOwin, well I would use place=neighbourhood for places that feel like a neighborhood and not necessarily 100% residential. Like Salcedo Village in Makati.

I am not sure about Photon but Nominatim does index named landuse=residential areas. Case in point: https://nominatim.openstreetmap.org/details.php?place_id=77697295

Or if the gated community is "small" enough, landuse=residential is enough.

Hi! May I know what these highway=steps are in the Camp Aguinaldo Golf Course? Please take note that highway=steps is meant to be used for stairs and stairways, such as the ones at the ends of pedestrian overpasses.

This is a pretty messy changeset that messes us routing at the Amorsolo exit of Skyway.