Hi t2editme,
Thank you for your contributions to openstreetmap in Maine.

I noticed in this change set that perhaps the inner and outer relations might be different than you intend. For example, Sawyer Pond (way/829792652) is inside the natural woods enclosed by way/1119243300. However, Sawyer pond is marked as "outer" in the relation and way/1119243300 is marked as "inner" rather than the reverse.

Cheers,
scarapella

@bluebasaur, thanks for all your OSM contributions around Kittery. I was wondering why you tagged some of these ways (e.g. 1092237165) as building=house;static_caravan when building=static_caravan seems to have the same meaning (and doesn't anger QA checks like osmose).

building=static_caravan

Thanks for all the great work you are doing on OSM in Maine!

Hello ybungalobill to quote waterway=stream "the commonly accepted rule for OpenStreetMap is that a stream can be jumped across by an active, able-bodied person" a more Maine based approach might be "if I can pole a canoe up it, it might be a river." ;-) So looking at Arnold Brook, I'd say from the mouth (~15m wide) to knights brook (~9m wide) is pretty comfortably a river. Above that, and especially above Chapman Road, I think it could go either way. I'd welcome your opinion.

Hi kartler175,

Which relations in particular are you concerned about. If you mean 14092249, yeah... not sure what I was doing there. I'm going to go fix that.

If you mean 14092316, I tend to go for Option B, but I'll admit, that's super arguable here.

However, perhaps your concern is broader and i'll be happy to hear from you.

cheers,
scarapella

Hi Kurusefahrer,

Updates are manual, which I think is good for the updating the names and links, but probably inefficient for any redrawing of water features in a large scale. I cross check against USGS, Esri and other imagery, and try to link to GNIS and wiki data where possible. My updates are generally to places I’ve been on the ground or adjacent areas.

Any concerns (or advice) are welcome.

Cheers
Scarapella