rskedgell's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 166917970 | I'm pretty sure that no part of Kiln Lane or the B4440 are highway=trunk. None of them is an A road with green primary route signage, which is what this tag means in the UK. Please read and ensure that you have understood the documentation before changing any other highway tags.
Reverted in changeset/166946284 |
|
| 34650140 | Vandalism, in this case by adding a fictitious weight restriction, doesn't improve routing. |
|
| 34674518 | How does adding a fictitious weight limit improve anything? |
|
| 166897093 | (Review requested) Thanks for spotting this. The outer member of the Eden Dock multipolygon shouldn't have add any tags, which was my error in an earlier edit. Fixed in changeset/166903540 |
|
| 166852850 | If it's private, you probably want access=private rather than access=no
|
|
| 166811426 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap and thanks for adding your business. I've changed it from shop=supermarket to shop=trade + trade=building_supplies, which seems to be the best fit currently available in OSM. The documentation for this is at:
|
|
| 166694018 | (Review requested) You might consider splitting addr:housename="8 Quadrum Park" into either: addr:unit=8
or |
|
| 166688502 | Candidates for CMI and CIPD membership might expect any reasonable reading of their codes of practice to preclude advertising methods which are the digital equivalent of fly posting over a street sign. |
|
| 166673728 | Thanks for confirming, restored in changeset/166690175 |
|
| 166681436 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap. I can see from your website that you operate from 84 Strathville Road, but what your edit has inadvertently done is to remove the building from the map. If your company premises occupy the whole building, then you might want to add something like office=company and/or an appropriate value of craft=*, together with tags for contact details and website. This lets data consumers know what sort of map feature you are, as they won't see your website address in the changeset comment. If the business occupies only part of the building, it might be better to map it as a separate node (point). I've added links to the documentation for the tags below, but if you'd like any help please reply below. |
|
| 166644897 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap and thanks for updating this. If you wanted to add the gates as well, you could add nodes (points) with the tags barrier=gate + foot=private + locked=yes. It's not absolutely necessary to add them and the tags you added will work on their own, so feel free to ignore this suggestion. |
|
| 166655188 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap and thanks for adding your business. Do you occupy the whole building on the corner of Tooting High Street and Garratt Lane, or the ground floor unit between Halifax and JJ Moon's (I think this may have been Rozu Restaurant previously, based on FHRS data)? |
|
| 166673728 | You have also moved the tags of a hump on Crimscott Street to the entrance of Bridewain Street. 1) Has the speed hump on Crimscott Street been removed? 2) Has the row of concrete bollards acting as a modal filter on Bridewain Street been supplemented by a speed hump? The ref:GB:tflcid=RWG079969 tag applies only to one surveyed feature in one location, which is clearly not on Bridewain Street.
|
|
| 166562364 | (Review requested) Although the web-based iD editor which you're using presents several access options as if they ought to be completed, a way (line) tagged as highway=footway implies foot=yes and (everything else)=no. You only really need to add access tags where they differ from the defaults, which in the UK are listed here:
|
|
| 166441244 | Thanks! With all the 20mph zone boundary signs confirmed, I've added the speed limit tags for the whole zone in changeset/166465132 |
|
| 166410405 | Has the car park in West Harrow Recreation Ground formerly(?) accessed from Wilson Gardens/Butler Road also been removed? You have deleted its access road in this changeset. |
|
| 166420936 | You seem to have dragged an artwork in Kensington Gardens, London, UK out of place in this changeset. |
|
| 166426886 | With Eden Dock Bridge now open, should access=no be replaced with foot=permissive ? |
|
| 166277900 | Why replace direction=* (understood by all data consumers) with traffic_sign:direction=*, an iD-ism introduced in 2018? |
|
| 166235532 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap. Although adding bicycle=no on the N-S highway=footway does no harm, it doesn't actually do anything either as it's implcit.
For the E-W highway=cycleway, if cycling is not permitted, you should probably change the highway type. Looking at the Bing street side imagery it seems to be wide enough for service vehicles and has a removable bollard, so perhaps:
|