OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
43521892

Can I remind you of the lifecycle concept, so one can put 'disused:' in front of the primary key (in this case amenity).
For more detail see: osm.wiki/Lifecycle_prefix
Alternatively if the phone box has been totally removed, one can just delete the node in OSM.

45014996

Hmm something wrong on JOSM upload, my comment was meant to be: "Junction name, signed incline and fix peak position."

40304344

I also read that it had reopened in WightWash (CAMRA IoW magazine) but I forgot to mention that.

44963942

The Wikidata ID for at least the Amsterdam Shipwreck was valid, so why did you remove it?

40304344

The Sportsmans Rest looks like it's reopened as I went past it the other day.
However for things that are closed you shouldn't really modify the name, but instead put 'disused:' in front of the primary key.
See osm.wiki/Lifecycle_prefix for more information

44784027

Hmm something wrong on JOSM upload, my comment was meant to be: "Postbox detail and public telephone has become a mini library"

42953117

I'm not sure where you get your information from as: 1) The Trafalgar has been closed since the end of summer 2016 and 2) The location is a bit inaccurate as it is nearer Edinburgh Road.

43560059

It's probably a good idea to mark this as private as it's not for general public use.

43521907

The original one is in the right position and also has more tags

43521907

Ummm Sant Yago is already mapped.

42921749

If the telephone is now removed - one should use the lifecycle concept to prevent others (and computers) thinking this is still operational.
Basically put 'disused:' in front of the primary tag - in this case the amenity tag so it would become 'disused:amenity'.
For more detail see disused=*:

41967078

My comment was meant to be:

Southern Transit road is not for public use

40453931

You seemed to have made Worthing Road an angular bend here.
Surely it's more of a smooth curve?

40453931

You seemed to have made Worthing Road somewhat of an angular bend here.
Surely it's more of a smooth curve?

40446838

foot=yes is *not* needless on a highway=footway, typically it can elude to the path being an official Right of Way.
Often people used this tagging before the community settled on the unambiguous designation=public_footpath tagging.

39674107

You may want to get familiar to life cycle concepts to describe no longer 'active' features.
See disused=*:
This this should be tagged-
disused:amenity=postbox
Thus allowing map and data users to more easily understand the availability of features.

39849443

Pubs are normally tagged as amenity=pub not shop=bathroom_furnishing!

You possibly didn't mean to move the bus stop either...

39544390

'a' is not a useful comment.
Please try to describe your changes (and why you made them) to help other mappers understand your edits.

24262177

What is your source for these 'peaks'.
Most seem just to be vaguely near high point of a bit of landscape (as seen by a OS 1-inch 7th Series 1955-61 spot height), which IMHO is not a peak.

37528637

I'm not sure how this 'fixes' tags.
Anything machine reading tag that can handle ';' should be able to handle white space.

Besides it's probably simpler just to tag it as one amenity type (i.e. a restaurant - as it's even in their web address - http://www.poppinsrestaurants.co.uk/)