ralley's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 161350748 | You are continuing to add phone numbers in the wrong format and edit numbers that were in the correct format. See phone=* |
|
| 161127702 | Is this really concrete? It looks more like asphalt in the LINZ and Bing aerial imagery |
|
| 161187296 | Additionally in this and many other of your change sets you are wrongly changing the phone number format from E.164. Please see phone=* |
|
| 161043993 | It looks like for this and other edits you are appending "halal" in the name field to indicate that the amenity caters for halal diets. Looking at https://kebabseraibirkenhead.co.nz/ it seems the actual name is "Kerab Serai" and the halal should be tagged as "diet:halal=yes" (see diet:halal=*)
|
|
| 161127700 | Is the service road (WAY: 297477811) really concrete? It looks like asphalt from aerial imagery
|
|
| 160850285 | Why have you removed the service road within the carpark (WAY: 1110654367)? It still appears in the aerial imagery you refer to
|
|
| 160456497 | Thanks for addressing this, sorry I didn't reply earlier
|
|
| 160015074 | Source was actually survey, see Mapillary imagery |
|
| 158475197 | Hi, steps=yes is an actively discouraged tagging style, see highway=steps
|
|
| 158475355 | Bing maps show the house to the south of here appears to be gone. |
|
| 158475355 | You have added a park and removed a building here with only the LINZ NZ aerial imagery and no source listed. The change does not appear in the imagery - what is the actual source? |
|
| 158360616 | Also Puhinui details from visit. Sources also survey and Mapillary (still uploading) |
|
| 158319653 | Changeset description was wrong, actually updated completed apartments |
|
| 157899766 | Please use meaningful comments in your changesets: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments
|
|
| 155976483 | Review as requested: Adding the building for the store looks good but the store is now mapped as both a node and a polygon (the building). The node shpould instead be replaced by the building so that the principle of "one feature, one OSM element" is followed: osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element
|
|
| 154252618 | You have changed the name of Clarence Street West to Calrence Street yet as seen in this June 2024 imagery (https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=-36.8288956&lng=174.7928306&z=17&pKey=1655430748603131&focus=photo&x=0.6564028295139888&y=0.3780451361608255&zoom=1.1264080100125153). The signposted name includes "West", can you please advise what your source for this change was? |
|
| 148791850 | This change also dragged the address node for 25 Hugh Green Drive. (node/5513377408). Fixed. |
|
| 134750030 | You have changed way/102297848 from a building to a park which appears from aerial imagery to be wrong, was this deliberate?
|
|
| 134515853 | Thanks for adding the driveway but once again you have added a made up name. As per osm.wiki/Names#Name_is_the_name_only the name tag is for genuine names only.
|
|
| 57280475 | Not intentional, fixed |