Hi SekeRob,
you mapped something with emergency=disasterr_response here. Do you have more details about this place? What is it called? Who operates it? Does the object fit the now approved definition of emergency=disaster_response?
node/8603407825
emergency=disaster_response

I didn't mean that life rings are not important in general. They are just very small and not always interesting. But that depends on the use case of the data consumer.

emergency=defibrilator is also not rendered on OSM-carto. Example:
node/11304832734
It is the same with emergency=fire_hydrant. Example:
node/3798292277

OSM-carto, the default map you see on openstreetmap.org, is just one of many use cases of the OSM data. It is still important/usefull to map objects that are not rendered here. There is for example openfiremap:
http://www.openfiremap.de/?zoom=14&lat=49.46043&lon=11.11525&layers=B00000T
When zoomed in enough you see every emergency=fire_hydrant as a red dot.

So if someone wants to offer a map showing every emergency=life_ring they can do it pretty easily, if they are existent in the OSM-database.

I hope I was able to help you. If you still have any questions feel free to ask them.

Hallo benjaminalbrecht,
du hast hier einen THW Ortsverband entfernt. Dabei hast du operator:wikidata=Q697698 stehen lassen. War das absicht? Wird das Gebäude noch durch das THW genutzt?

What you describe is tagging for the renderer:
osm.wiki/Tagging_for_the_renderer

You added a tag not because it adds real world information but just to get a subjectivly nice map in your favourite renderer. That is not good practice. Please abstain from that practice.

Personally I do not think that life rings should be rendered on OSM-carto. I am not sure but I think even before my removal of amenity=emergency they where not rendered on OSM-carto. If we rendered every small and insicnificant object the map would be very crowded. Specalised maps like openseamap could render such objects. If you want them to render them you need to get in contact with the author of the renderer and ask them. If they decide to render them than thats fine.

Hi RexTCA,
you used a strange tagging here, probably a typo: "emergency"="fire_hydrant:tyepe=pillar"

Can you have a look on the objects of this changeset?

I have the same question for this place:
way/828941557

Hello albertoq,
you edited an emergency=ses_station here. This tag got deprecated a few weeks ago. Is emergency=disaster_response a fitting replacement?

way/374547546

emergency=disaster_response

Thanks for the quick feedback. I updated the tagging.

Thanks for the response. That sound like we need help here from others. I opened a note:
note/4134461

Hello CENTSOARER,
you added an object with emergency=ses_station. This tag is deprecated. Is emergency=disaster_response a fitting replacement?

changeset/94927879

emergency=disaster_response

Hallo teranowicz,
was ist ein amenity="emergency ambulance"? Meinst du emergency=ambulance_station?

way/883140163

emergency=ambulance_station

Hi ToteyGeo,
I think you made a typo here. See the amenity=* tag.

node/11093804232

Hi OKANO Takayoshi,
can you maybe help with this question?
note/4134409

Hallo thom3,
was ist ein amenity=emergency?

node/2964122253

Thanks for the response. I remooved the tag.

Thanks for the response. I updated the tagging.

Thanks for the response. That makes sense. To prevent confusion at a later point I added a note=*:
node/4112641175

Hi Ewen Hill,
is this a station of the Queensland SES?
way/867737651

Hi TheOldMiner,
is this a station of the Queensland SES?
way/488980290

Hi Warin61,
is this a station of the Queeensland SES?
way/1189586983