OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
143021827

the state and US routes like North Ave were built to function differently with more lanes and less traffic lights for faster travel times.

143021827

It feels like it should be classed differently than other downtown streets only because it is an iconic street. the functionality is the same as other secondary roads downtown and actually slower to use than the other adjacent roads.

136642963

ahh, fixed. Tower 12 is the name of the control tower, Wabash-Van Buren Junction was the official name of the actual junction, but the tower numbers "Tower 12 Junction" have become prominent for the common names.

138511282

I can see argument there.. since the bus lane physically separates the turn lane from the others. It would be better to map them as such and then it would make more since to combine that small stretch with the turn lane.

138511282

I didn't think the lines need combined for 100ft of shared turnlane.

137118516

Western is neither a state route or US route. so secondary is a correct tag.

137681046

There is still the section where the bridge was that is still marked as no access, under construction, so routing isn't available until that is marked open.

136589579

most of the bike lanes downtown are being converted to separated lanes. ive noticed a lot of work needs done on bikemap around chicago

135318668

I can agree to the class.

135717700

One thing to know is there is no correct way to tag a feature on OSM.
area:highway was resurrected from an abandoned proposal, something not toughly talked though by collaborating mappers, and just one of the reasons it is not rendered by the main maps.
This area was mapped using the
highway=footway + area=yes method which is also commonly used. Linear paths were added because path area=yes were not routable features and was requested. But if you would also want to add area:highway as an additional tag along with highway=footway + area=yes that would be ok.

135317508

i made a page for the Chicago metro area for discussion. osm.wiki/Chicago_Area/Highway_Classification

135317508

The discussion and collaboration died when OSM community ambassador Dirk Munson left the company. I havn't seen any meetups since.

135317508

Was sticking to US and State routes marked as primary. Major buisness lined roads that traverse the highways and rivers as secondary, other major roads and county routes as tertiary, separated highways as motorway, and partially separated highways / connector highways as trunk. At least that is what is was originally within the Chicago area until someone started playing around with an unfinished proposal.
I've toyed a bit upgrading some of the loop area streets as primary for connectivity, part of michigan avenue, ohio street, ida b wells. but at what point do you not just mark all of the major roads as primary? Those roads dont nessesarily mean it is the prefered rout of everyone, or that its even the fastest route though the area. The US/state routes from my experience are actually better to drive because they have more lanes and less traffic lights along those routes. It really needs to be discussed a bit more.

135318668

osm.wiki/United_States_roads_tagging/Routes#Honorary_and_Tourist_Routes I did give it an extra HIST as that is what the signage says.

133979842

ahh, I did see that, didnt have a lot of info but, made some adjustments and it seems to look accurate now. Ill have to scour the web and see if i can find some belter diagrams.

133979842

When did this change take place? I didn't know there was any revised plan? source link?

133938125

Please do not edit indoor features without using indoor editors and reviewing the how-to of indoor editing.

133941522

one example of these edits that have been happening are changeset/133938278

133938278

Why did you add extra elevators to the route and connect routes on multiple levels?

133941522

I originally had the routes marked footways, but some editors had recently started changing a bunch to indoor corridors and remapping multilevel footways on a single level adding connection/elevators exe.. where they shouldn't be. I recently had to remap everything and switched the multilevel routes to corridors to settle the bad indoor routing that was being created.

I am not opposed to swithcing the main roues tags to highway=footway+indoor=yes but highway=corridor also needs be able to be routed for foot directions.

I am a frequent visitor at Ohare being my home airport. But I originally uesd the official Ohare maps combined with some of the airline terminal maps provided on their apps, some resent video tours found on youtube and my personal knowledge to create the indoor maps and routes. I used indoor editors such as ID-indoor and OsmInEdit while creating the indoor maps.