Hi, thanks for adding to the map in Minnesota. Just an FYI, this area is St. Paul, you might want to double-check your changeset comments in the future to make sure they're accurate! :)

Hi, and welcome to OSM! Happened to notice this edit and have a couple suggestions: 1) this is not the right tag for a business, highway=services is used for rest areas. Maybe shop=car_repair would be better? 2) OSM is generally for what is "on the ground", but there are lifecycle prefixes that can be used for features that are planned/proposed/under construction. See osm.wiki/Lifecycle_prefix

Hi, welcome to OSM! I noticed in this changeset you tagged parking lots with highway=service. You should only tag the actual lanes within the lot that way. Also, you tagged some churches with religion=* and denomination=*. Just leave these blank if you don't know. One last thing, landuse is not usually used on buildings. You can find more info about it on the wiki's landuse page: osm.wiki/Landuse Happy mapping!

Hi from looking at the aerial imagery, it doesn't appear there is a pond or park at this location. Do you have an explanation? Thanks

I noticed your very detailed work on the golf course--nice! However, it's tagging for the renderer to use highway=path for the golf=hole way.

1) it looks clearly parceled to me--have you looked at the Bing imagery? 2) I live in this area and know a lot of community gardens, they are run *as described on the allotments page*. Unless you have some local knowledge to the contrary please change the garden's tag back. Thanks.

BTW, parks data is also available from the county government's open data portal here: http://gis-hennepin.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/c76bcca7eb564523b6a1cf2807cbc481_3

Sorry I did not notice the copyright on the city website. However, you're wrong about the garden, see the allotments page on the wiki "Allotment gardens are characterised by a concentration in one place of a few or up to several hundreds of land parcels that are assigned to individuals or families" Maybe it's different in Germany, but in the US that describes community gardens.

Pretty clearly a community garden from the imagery, and here's a reference: https://www.stlouispark.org/bronx-park/bronx-park-neighborhood.html I used the city map for Nelson Park boundaries: https://www.stlouispark.org/webfiles/file/ir/2016/citywidemap-24x24.pdf But yeah looks like it may have changed with construction?

Welcome and thanks for contributing to OpenStreetMap! Remember that OSM is data for everyone's use, so things like the house address or building outline will be more useful than what you've entered.

what about a street address?

Is that a pool? Try leisure=swimming_pool instead :)

I think that's better. I'd just use the "merge" for areas contained by other areas. If there are adjacent areas with the same tag, I think you need to merge them more manually. In case it helps, I did a couple others (the ponds N of 100th and W of 143rd, the island in the N end of the lake). If you view them in iD, you'll see info in the members and/or relations sections.

Just trying to give you some friendly advice/feedback from someone who's contributed a lot, before you make a lot of detailed but sub-optimal edits that may impact you or another map editor/data user in the future.

Welcome to OSM! Wondering why you split the park into two pieces when they are overlapping? Appears it could just be one big area.

So, why not just make one big grass area? Or if you really want to do detailed micro-mapping, grass areas should end next to the paths. (I just edited the small triangle west of the pitches in this way in case you're unsure what I mean)

I'm wondering why you are adding wikidata tags to individual highway ways (ie way/45782591), and not to relations that collect those ways in a route (ie relation/1630660)?

Welcome to OSM. I'm wondering why you created so many different grass areas in this park? It appears they are bounded by the paths. It seems overcomplicated and having the areas along the paths makes it harder to edit in the future. Plus, the grassy areas outside the paths are not tagged.

Welcome to OSM! I notice that in these edits you've tried to create "islands" in landuse areas in the wrong way. You should be using multipolygon relations. See osm.wiki/Relation:multipolygon on the wiki for a description, and the Relations section of the iD Editor help for how to create them.

wondering why you added sport=sport_centre to the Power Sport shop?