OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
74860481

Great - didn't see the restriction on the traffic light - just looked at the bollard :-)

74851721

I will be changing some of your modifications, as I think your bus survey could have missed some details, e.g. there's a combined cycle and footway all the way along:

https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=51.43762039018646&lng=-2.6231131596663397&z=17&pKey=2vpAWQV3Wadci-b3I3ciug&focus=map

74851721

Looks like some typos in stop names?:
Ss Great Britain
Queen Square (Q1')

74851721

How did you survey this?

I mapped the guided busway by walking it on foot and was extremely careful -- and I'm not sure about some of your changes.

I'll admit I probably used psv when I should have used bus.

74860481

I can't see any no U-turn signs on Bing Streetside or Mapillary -- could you please post a link.

74801326

Bus stops were originally imported from NAPTAN -- under OGL (see https://data.gov.uk/dataset/ff93ffc1-6656-47d8-9155-85ea0b8f2251/national-public-transport-access-nodes-naptan).

Ideally, you would be able to say the same licence (or something similar) applied to any information you are adding:names / locations / disuse, etc.

If you can't that's a problem. It could cause problems with other mappers and users of the data (commercial and otherwise) exposing them to the (potential) threat of litigation -- or at least having all your edits redacted osm.org/redactions/

If you'd followed the import guidelines -- then you'd have considered any licencing issues.

74826059

Couldn't see steps tonight (it's boarded up) but shape seems close to map now.

Sometimes it's difficult to tell what's intentional when the river gets moved.

74801326

I'll try and check the names tonight.

Regards copyright -- I'll flag it with the data working group -- they should have a better idea than me whether you are using a work derived from Ordnance Survey data.

74826059

Cheers, that's a good first start.

Presume is still WIP given all the construction lines. Pretty sure "The Wellhead" was rectangular when I surveyed it -- looks a bit odd now.

74817920

Presume you're reverting this too?
A lot of stuff seems to have been "sheared" -- https://nrenner.github.io/achavi/?changeset=74817920

74801326

As for the particular issue of the bus stop names -- it's clear that the name is "The Centre" (https://www.flickr.com/photos/184597061@N05/48783615901/in/dateposted-public/ and https://www.flickr.com/photos/184597061@N05/48783611851/in/dateposted-public/)

74801326

The PDF is "(c) Crown Copyright and database rights 2019, Ordnance Survey 100023406" -- if you're mapping/copying from that then that's going to be problematic.

I *really* don't want to upset you -- but you *do* need to check out the copyright situation -- OSM can't use anything from Ordnance Survey that isn't explicitly licenced. If it really is open data why isn't it on https://opendata.bristol.gov.uk/pages/homepage/

74801326

The large bus stops are called "The Centre" -- there's little evidence for C1/C2. Might be on some digital display, but not on major infrastructure items -- there's a strong argument to revert this change to on the ground surveyed data.

Note: the C1/C2 were kept on the "official_name".

74750510

I've removed the names that are housenumbers.

70617844

The changeset was trying to correct the road geometries that had been dragged about badly.

Apologies if I upset something else.

74536525

Looks like a ferry route got dragged north-east -- some strange artifacts on riverbanks near ferry terminals.

74528913

Bristol Power Signal Box (and its chimney) used to match ESRI Clarity - not sure what it's matching now? Maybe stuff got dragged -- there's a wobble in the parking lane near Bristol Power Signal Box. GPS data isn't conclusive -- matched old version as well (if not better) than the new one?

74451791

Can't see any no U-turn signs on Bing -- are you sure it's there?

74179599

Moved to OSM message.

74179599

Ok, it seems that you don't have a good idea of the licence or copyright of the data you are adding - and whether it's compatible with odbl, i.e. the openstreetmap licence. I wouldn't add any more until you can clarify things - it's probably something you should check.