mtmail's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 132595491 | What does "BB KeyChain #1" mean? It's not a postcode (ZIP code). Imagery suggests the position is a residential address. I can't find any other information online when looking for BB KeyChain or the changeset comment. |
|
| 131343044 | You can see them here https://nominatim.org/qa/#map=13.16/52.38/17.08&layer=postcode_bad_format but I fixed them already today. No problem. With the source=swarzedz.e-mapa.net I wasn't sure how much is automated. |
|
| 131343044 | Are the address updates part automated? The addr:postcode is '-' for three separate addresses in OSM. Maybe that can be avoided in the future? |
|
| 130281387 | Is name=<NULL> caused by an automated script? |
|
| 129249847 | I think node/9071769370 has house number 7 but I don't unclear where the 68C from the addr:postcode field belongs to |
|
| 121104988 | way/1061094999 has house number 60, but nearby way/1061094990 also has 60. Is it possible that it should be 45? There is a 45 at the end of the addr:postcode. Might be a copy&paste error |
|
| 32572933 | I don't have local knowledge in the area. You can delete the place of course. Or add disused: or abandoned: or removed: (osm.wiki/Lifecycle_prefix) |
|
| 125470720 | Hello Claudio, Please do use meaningful changeset comments - “m” does not help other mappers understand what you are doing. |
|
| 125099292 | Die Postleitzahl bei diesen Gebäuden ist 6 stellig. Ist die korrekte 5 stellige bekannt? https://nominatim.org/qa/#map=15.71/49.96/6.52&layer=postcode_bad_format |
|
| 124035946 | addr:postcode enthält '14'. Ist das eventuell eine Hausnummer? |
|
| 123033483 | Auf https://www.ase-edv.eu/impressum/ stehen zwei Adressen. Habe jetzt die Landshuter statt der Wiener eingetragen. |
|
| 124688165 | Bei Gebäude way/164387642 ist eine '25' in das Postleitzahl Feld eingetragen. Gehört die 25 eventuell zu einem anderen Gebäude in der Nähe? |
|
| 124455346 | What does "Unconfirmed housenumber as there is none listed on google" mean? Have you copied data, e.g. other house numbers, from Google Maps? |
|
| 124374211 | Ist bei dem linken/westlichen Gebäude die Hausnummer eventuell nur 51 statt 51-63? Die Postleitzahl ist vermutlich auch nicht die richtige bei dem Gebäude. |
|
| 123492635 | Why was boundary=adminstrative changed to boundary=route for a county? (osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Relation:route&uselang=en) The changeset comment is only 'la county'. I'll change it back but please let me know if there's a misunderstanding on my side. |
|
| 123282840 | Can you provide evidence that the english spelling is widely used? ü is not on many people's keyboards for example. Related https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Turkey#Name_change |
|
| 69089536 | Canadapost claims copyright on their postcode database and sued companies in the past for reusing their data. While postcodes themselves are considered facts and shouldn't be able to be copyright-able so far the courts have decided in Canadapost's favor. Copying data from their website, or any other commercial dataset, and adding it to OpenStreetMap is not permitted. Somewhat related discussion https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/talk-ca/2020-June/009784.html If you do a survey, e.g. see the postcode printed on the letterbox in front of the building, it can be added to OpenStreetMap. But their website is an extension of their database and coping many (in this case it seems 1200) postcodes would be copyright infringement. I wish less buildings were affected and I know mapping is a lot of work but the data license isn't compatible with the OpenStreetMap license. I've emailed https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/wiki/Data_Working_Group on 2022-05-31. If you feel treated unfairly we can ask them to immediate or clarify. |
|
| 69089536 | Deleted all 1295 postcodes added by this user. Happy to have a discussion, possibly revert some deletions but I've come overwhelmingly and sadly come to the conclusion it was copied from Gmaps. |
|
| 120354633 | The wikipedia page of node/151668218 says the place is locationed at/on the Rio Grande. I believe it describes node/151789456 instead |
|
| 69089536 | Hi Bruno, Regarding way/682949653 "Ajouter une adresse manquante Ajouter votre établissement Ajouter un libellé Photos" (Add a missing, place, Add your business, Add a label
Can you explain which data was copied from Google Maps? Postal codes? House numbers? All the best |