ok of niet ok?

ok of niet ok?

And now you should correct your typo: "builidng" :)
Marc.

Hi,
way/924956011
landuse=cliff on a closed way?
Shouldn't that be natural=cliff on a line?
Marc.

Yes I think so, because muddy=yes is a tag that is not rendered nor understood by the dataconsumers. And if it is muddy, is it muddy all the time? Is it muddy because of recent rainfall? If not, then intermittent=yes should be added.
Any tag you like is great, but if a tag is only used once, it is worth thinking of a replacement.

relation/4481309
Hi Peter,
Gelukkig nieuw jaar!
Wat is "Resultaat=Wilgenplantsoen 16 Waspik" voor rare tagging?
Groet,
Marc

way/175820969/history
Hi Glassman,
Happy New Year!
Why did you write all the keys with capslock on?
See this: osm.wiki/Any_tags_you_like#How_to_name_new_tags
Marc.

way/688673876
Hoi Lachgast,
payment:museumkaart wordt veel gebruikt, maar waarom voeg je ook nog museumkaart=yes toe. Die tag wordt wereldwijd één keer gebruikt (door jou) en voegt volgens mij niets toe.
Groetjes en mooi 2022!
Marc.

way/681236804
You have used a very rare key:
barefoot=yes
You are the only person in the world using that key!
What does it mean?

Can you be a bit more specific than just "mapping"? Isn't that what we all are doing?
osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

node/2807473878
Hi Derick,
7 years ago, on that bench you also put the tagging "winniedepooh=yes".
Shouldn't that be: "name=Winnie the Pooh", because the key winniedepooh is only used once (by you), and hence not very helpful.
Or is there some hidden meaning?
Have a great new year!
Marc.

Thanks, I have asked that user also for an explanation now.

way/319016481

Hi Rongel,
You changed historic=yes to historic=4.
Please read:
osm.wiki/Key%3Ahistoric and start_date=*
as historic=* cannot be a date.
Was it a mistake?
Marc.

Gracias por la explicación
Un saludo.
Marc.

node/9189150790
What is amenity=3 supposed to mean?
author=* is also not a valid key. Do you mean source=*?
Please correct.
Marc.

Hello,
way/208684315/history
landuse=1 is not a valid expression for landuse and it also has no function on a highway.
What do you mean?

== [deepl translation]
landuse=1 n'est pas une expression valide pour landuse=* et elle n'a pas non plus de fonction sur une highway=*.
Que voulez-vous dire ?
Merci.
Marc.

way/254561724/history
Hola Javier,
You have used historic=1935 for this object, but the historic key is used to describe objects, not dates.
osm.wiki/Key%3Ahistoric
You also used start_date, which seems to be right. But what are you trying to describe with historic=1935?
[deepl translation]
Has utilizado historic=1935 para este objeto, pero la clave historic se utiliza para describir objetos, no fechas.
osm.wiki/Key%3Ahistoric
También has utilizado start_date, que parece ser correcto. Pero, ¿qué intentas describir con historic=1935?
Gracias,
Marc.

way/866654883
Hola Pedro,
Has añadido al mapa una power=plant en este lugar, pero en las imágenes aéreas (PNOA) no se ve nada de eso.
Veo sobre todo tierras de cultivo.
¿Qué fuente has utilizado?
Estoy haciendo un montón de landuse=orchard y landuse=vineyard en esa zona.
Gracias,
Marc.

Danke für das Update!

Should this be reverted?

Marc Zoutendijk
OpenStreetMap Foundation
Data Working Group