OpenStreetMap
jake-low's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 111112787 | The feature you're asking about is the location of the camp host (the caretaker of the campground), which is where you check in if you have a reservation. It's not inside a building, it's just a tourism=camp_pitch where the host stays. I tagged it as camp_site=reception as recommended at the time by the tourism=camp_site page. It seems that since then the tagging recommendations have changed; I don't know the correct way to tag it now. |
|
| 171513664 | I merged this trailhead with the other POI for the same trailhead nearby
|
|
| 171513674 | I fixed a typo in this trailhead's name ("Alum Cave Trailhead Trailhead")
|
|
| 171514109 | FYI, it looks like this changeset accidentally included a couple of redundant trailhead nodes. I've edited them again to fix this.
|
|
| 171514231 | FYI, I've removed this trailhead since it doesn't meet OSM's definition (a place where someone could start a hike or journey), since it's deep in the wilderness at the USFS/NPS boundary. This was an issue with the source dataset, not with your edit. Thanks for your contributions!
|
|
| 171513997 | I don't think this campground exists; the linked webpage says dispersed camping is available along the riverbank and floodplains, but this precise location isn't a campground.
|
|
| 171514485 | Hello, thanks for your contribution. I've deleted this campground because it does not appear to exist based on any available satellite imagery. As mentioned in the MapRoulette challenge instructions, please make sure the campground actually exists before adding it.
|
|
| 171514539 | Note: I made a follow-up edit to reattach the trail to the road network, to make sure routing will work in navigation apps
|
|
| 171514641 | FYI, I've removed this particular trailhead because it doesn't meet OSM's definition of a trailhead (a place where someone could start a hike or other journey), because it's deep in the wilderness at the NPS/USFS boundary. Thanks for all your edits on the trailhead mapping project!
|
|
| 171514663 | Just FYI, it looks like you accidentally added two trailhead nodes for the same object in this edit. I've made a follow-up edit and merged them together. Thanks for all of your contributions!
|
|
| 171514696 | This campground doesn't appear to exist at all, I've deleted it (I'm the author of the MapRoulette task this edit was associated with, and am reviewing all contributions)
|
|
| 171514788 | I agree; I've removed this campground (I'm the author of the MapRoulette task this contribution was associated with, and am in the process of reviewing features that were added)
|
|
| 171518799 | FYI, I removed this trailhead (similar to another one you added that I also commented on). Nothing wrong with your edit, just that while NPS considers this a "trailhead" because it's at the edge of their management area, it's deep in the wilderness and isn't considered a trailhead by OSM since it's not a place people can start a journey.
|
|
| 171518905 | I moved the trailhead to beside the parking area, and retagged this point as an unmarked crossing
|
|
| 171519013 | Thanks for all your edits to add missing trailhead nodes! I've reviewed many of them and they look great. Just wanted to let you know that I deleted this one; this "trailhead" was present in the NPS dataset but I don't think it qualifies as a trailhead in OSM's definition since there's no trail system that you can access from this point (just a very short footpath to a historic site). Nothing wrong with your edit, just a quirk in the data source we have been using that I've been correcting during review.
|
|
| 171519013 | Thanks for all your edits to add missing trailhead nodes! I've reviewed many of them and they look great. Just wanted to let you know that I deleted this one; this "trailhead" was present in the NPS dataset but I don't think it qualifies as a trailhead in OSM's definition since there's no trail system that you can access from this point (just a very short footpath to a historic site). Nothing wrong with your edit, just a quirk in the data source we have been using that I've been correcting during review.
|
|
| 171519313 | I moved the location of this trailhead to the edge of the parking area (just outside the park boundary); it had originally been placed at a fork a ways up the trail, inside the park boundary.
|
|
| 171519322 | As I mentioned in a comment on another of your changesets, disconnecting the trail from the roadway like you've done here will break routing in most applications. I've re-connected the trail to the roadway and placed the trailhead at the correct place, see here: osm.org/edit?editor=id&node=889364338#map=20/38.1631656/-109.7625864 Feel free to message me if you have any questions about trail mapping.
|
|
| 171519328 | I've fixed the problem for this particular edit; see osm.org/edit#map=20/38.1572440/-109.7516994 for an example of how this should be mapped.
|
|
| 171519328 | Thanks for your edits! FYI, when adding a trailhead, it's important to keep the trail connected to the road network (instead of creating a small gap like you've done here). If there's a gap in the network, then people won't be able to get directions from one part to another.
|