Hi,

Thanks for contributing to the map!

Just as a note, road names aren't supposed to be abbreviated (see osm.wiki/Names#Abbreviation_(don't_do_it)). Would you mind fixing the road names? Thanks!

Hi,

This changeset introduced several duplicate nodes:
node/10695315851 duplicate of node/10689801264
node/10695315552 duplicate of node/10689801355
node/10695315482 duplicate of node/10689801252
node/10695315590 duplicate of node/10689801222

Could you please fix these? Thanks!

Hi,

This changeset introduced duplicates of several nodes:
node/10694121311 duplicate of node/10689773793
node/10694121272 duplicate of node/10689772743
node/10694121990 duplicate of node/10689771700

Could you please fix these? Thanks!

and also this one: way/1137010397

Also this way: way/1137010398

Hi,

You created this way with no tags, could you please tag it? way/1137010388#map=18/33.87281/-112.09544

Thanks!

Hi,

You created this way with no tags, can you please tag it? way/1137326358

Thanks!

Once again:

way/318517258#map=15/35.5916/-112.0520 is not a ford for the entire length of the way, please fix it

You mispelled 'natural' in the tags of way/47266256 and way/47266258, please fix those too

Hi,

This changeset introduced node/10700367293, which is a duplicate of node/9560671127, could you please fix this? Thanks!

Hi,

This changeset introduced node/10700307247 which is a duplicate of node/9280725370, can you please fix this? Thanks!

Also, (sorry for the individual comments, wasn't expecting to have to point out this many mistakes in a changeset), you removed the natural=water tag but left water=stream_pool on way/47186176. The water=stream_pool tag requires the natural=water tag (see water=stream%20pool?uselang=en) so please fix this as well

also, once again, names cannot be abbreviated in OSM, so please fix all the abbreviated names you created.

Also can you please explain what waterway=ArtificialPath is? you're literally the only mapper in the world using it, since it changes the meaning you should at least document it somewhere

I don't think this entire way is a ford, can you please fix it? way/318435371

Hi,

I noticed a few things in these ways you created:
way/173346301
way/1144544322
way/1144544315
way/1144544318

First, the road name is abbreviated, which is not allowed on OpenStreetMap, it needs to be fully expanded "West Gleed Station Road", etc (see osm.wiki/Names#Abbreviation_(don't_do_it) for more information)
Second, you removed the highway tag, so now they aren't roads at all and are useless for routers and data consumers.
Third, you tagged surface=ash, which I think was a typo for surface=asphalt?

Could you please fix these? Thanks!

Also did you mean to delete the driveway here? https://pewu.github.io/osm-history/#/way/968813975

Hi,

You deleted node/4151775510/history in this changeset, but didn't replace it with another amenity=fuel. Is this gas station closed?

Hi,

On way/1149288692 you put lanes:backward and lanes:forward on a oneway street, could you take a look and fix that? Thanks!

Hi,

In relation/15535534 you gave way/902654314 the 'outer' role, did you mean to give it the 'inner' role?

Hi,

This changeset created node/10698163229, which is a duplicate of node/9947526590, could you please fix it? Thanks!