Hi there,

Are you sure this is a hamlet? It seems more like a neighborhood, since it's a built up area with no legal designation that i can find

Right, but that isn't reflected in the route master relation right now.

Only the southbound route is mapped (relation/11246423). The northbound route was mapped as relation/11244652 but that was the one you changed to disused. So i was asking if you created a new northbound route, if you didn't, then it might be easiest to revert 11244652 back and just update the route to match the southbound one.

Actually, it's still in the route master relation for the Blueline, and I only see relation/11246423 for Gallatin Center → MSU Strand Union but i don't see a route relation for the opposite way. Is there one that i'm missing?

Alright, if it's really old then I'll just delete it then so it's not confusing

Okay, so is the Blueline mapped in a different relation? If it isn't, then you should revert relation/11244652 back to that route, otherwise it would be nice to change the tag to reflect that it's a disused bus route, not a disused bus stop

Hi there,

Looks like you typoed the access tag on way/1322995724, could you please fix it? Thanks!

Hi there,

Did you mean to change this entire bus route to a bus_stop? relation/11244652/history

Thanks,

One small thing, it's just "slight_right", not "slight_rightturn", but other than that looks good!

Hi there,

For way/1328657605, did you mean for "Old Garfield Road" to be the name?

Hi there,

Once again, this golf course has been closed for almost a decade. Please stop mapping it

I was going to wait until you responded, but someone else changed it: changeset/158440386

> However, many navigation devices rely on OSM for their base map trip plotting. It simply is frustrating when OSM based GPS App's say: "Take the Exit" just as the physical separation occurs.. and it is physically impossible to take that exit.

That sounds like a bug in the app you're using. Also, choosing which lane to be in prior to the exit is best done with the "turn:lanes" and "destination:lanes" tags. Having those tags will allow map routers to send users to the correct lane before it changes to a solid white line.

The corrections look good, thanks for doing that!

Hi there,

Unfortunately this golf course closed down about a decade ago, so it shouldn't be on the map anymore

Hi there,

You broke way/45859648 by dragging a node, could you please fix this? Thanks!

Removed in changeset/158378273, please do not add personal information to the map, thanks

Hi there,

So actually, the way it was before, while not perfect, matched reality more than it does now. Splitting things like off/on ramps, turn lanes, etc. need to be done as close to physical separation as possible. By putting the junction as far back as you did, you're saying that it's physically impossible to change from the off-ramp lane to the normal highway lanes, which isn't true. Would you mind changing it back to the way it was?

Hi there,

On way/499569525/history and way/1322354659 you have conflicting values for "sidewalk" and "sidewalk:both", would you mind going back and fixing those? Thanks!

Reverted for vandalism in changeset/158246951

Yeah, looking back at should probably be shop=equestrian since it's selling tacks and spurs for horses, among other things, but i dont think i saw that value at the time. I'll change it

Hi there,

Thanks for the additions! For way/1324827931, the building tag should be the primary building type only. If there's multiple different organizations in that building, the best way to represent that is to create separate nodes (points) for each organization and put them on the building and then tag the building as building=government.

Reverted for vandalism in changeset/158046608, drawing buildings overtop of existing buildings