Hi there,

Thanks for the additions. A couple of questions, could you explain more about what node/12125617750 is supposed to be? Since there's no defining tags, no data consumer can understand it.

Also, for way/1309499473#map=19/44.621754/-85.756065, marked_trail should be the more common trailblazed (trailblazed=*) and also it needs to be tagged on the path itself, not a surrounding area

Hope this helps!

Hi there,

Did you mean to leave node/12138008386 disconnected from node/40448445?

Hi there,

Did you mean to add building=yes to way/1310852880?

Hi there,

I don't think this entire path is a boardwalk, could you please double check it? way/946566705

Hi there,

I've reverted this changeset here: changeset/155746755

There were several errors, including breaking a house, changing a driveway to a stream, and not adding crossing nodes or tunnels where streams crossed roads.

Please follow the editor walkthrough and read the wiki to understand the correct way to map waterways, and please pay attention to the warnings of the editor when you go to save.

Thanks!

Hi there,

Please see service=driveway for how to tag driveways, and please add the correct tags to way/1311070385

Thanks!

Hi there,

It's incorrect to connect the house to the road, could you please disconnect those two objects? Thanks!

It looks like OsmAnd was trying to route you to the middle of the trail. It might be because of this gate node/7616501292 so i added locked=no since it's usually not locked. Also I added a trailhead so that hopefully OsmAnd displays that in the search instead

Hi there,

I reverted this changeset in changeset/155714058 because it broke the Whitmore Lake boundary

Hi there,

Would really appreciate if you went back and did this. Since you deleted the linear ways which already existed, this is technically a form of vandalism (osm.wiki/Vandalism#Vandalism_and_other_types_of_bad_editing) "Purposeful removal or degradation of data that are known to be correct" and should be corrected quickly

Thanks!

Hi there,

I edited these roads a bit, I confirmed with aerials, Strava, and bing streetside that the tracks do still exist, so I reconnected them and tagged them as motor_vehicle=private, as well as added the fence. I'm not sure why OsmAnd routed you to that track, because it's a dead end, but generally speaking it's best to keep roads connected and tag them appropriately than to remove them

*unnecessary to specify them separately

Hi there,

Thanks for the edits! In OSM, kph is the default for speed, so you will need to add "mph" as seen here: maxspeed=*?uselang=en#Values

Also, when a road has the same forward and backward maxspeed, it's unnecessary to specify them, so you can remove those as well

Thanks!

Hi there,

Looks like this changeset broke way/416525373 and way/341981363 (see visualizations here: https://pewu.github.io/osm-history/#/way/341981363 and https://pewu.github.io/osm-history/#/way/416525373)

Would you please fix these? Thanks!

Hi there,

I merged your node with the already existing parking lot building, and renamed it to "Louis Campau Parking Ramp", since the skywalk is already mapped here: way/251406318#map=18/42.964527/-85.673307

Hi there,

For operator:type, you should use either public or government, not both, because data consumers won't understand the value as you've written it (and neither will other mappers). Assuming the Parks and Rec division is run by the city, then it should be government, otherwise it should be public.

Otherwise, looks good!

Hi there,

Looks like you accidentally left two names on way/556028808/ and way/400668870 when you merged them, could you go back and remove one of the names from each? Thanks!

Hi there,

If the roads are actually under construction, then you also need to change the highway tag to highway=construction (see highway=construction for more details) Would you mind fixing these? Thanks!

Hi there,

Thanks for the edits! For length and width, the value needs to be a single value, either in meters (preferably) or feet, not both. That way data consumers can correctly process it. Would you mind fixing these? Thanks!

Hi there,

This changeset broke the route relation for the A-2 here: relation/13816397/history#map=17/42.65342/-86.18958

Could you please fix it? Thanks!