OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
88296872

Welcome to OpenStreetMap,

I have reverted this changeset because it made numerous tagging mistakes. I will list them here.
1) The addr:city value for St. George is "St. George", not "St George".
2) You changed the address to be on "E Tabernacle St". This has two things wrong with it. First, OSM has a rule that addresses ought not to be abbreviated, so it would be "East Tabernacle Street". Second, this point is at the corner of North Main Street and West Saint George Boulevard, so it cannot be on East Tabernacle Street, which is a block further south.
3) You changed the opening_hours tag to an improper format. Refer to the Wiki for how it should be formatted.
4) You changed the phone tag to an improper format. Refer to the Wiki for how it should be formatted.
5) The description tag is for objective details not captured in other tags, not a marketing blurb.

I assume you want to move the business that was located here to another location. These are the steps to do that:
1) Remove tags related to the business from the old location, leaving only the address, since the address is still valid.
2) Create a new point where the new location is, and add tags relevant to the business at that new point. If the business is replacing a tenant that is already mapped, the tags for that old business should be removed.

87989702

Hi, I see that you requested review of this edit. In it you attached a residential road to the nearby landuse and tagged the surface as asphalt. Connecting roads to landuse is not recommended. Also when reviewing TIGER data, one should check if there should be a name on the road. If you had checked the "TIGER Roads 2019" option in the editor, you would have seen that the name of the road is West 4450 North. Adding the correct surface tag to the road was good.
Thank you for your contributions, and happy mapping!

87877659

This creek is named after a local pioneer named John P. Brown, not the famous abolitionist. Please check local sources. This page took less than 2 minutes to find: http://genealogytrails.com/colo/mesa/bio.html

87877259

This road is named after the canyon, not a person. When it's a common name, be sure to check local sources.

87876561

Hello,
The instructions on this task clearly say to
"Carefully check context, like the location of the feature compared to where the person lived, how well known that person is, [...] before confirming that the feature is named after the person. If you aren't certain, skip the task so that someone with local knowledge can check instead."
Please be more careful.

87866407

Hi,
In this edit you delete a bunch of buildings and add new buildings in nearly the same spot. Also, you do not add back all of the tags. If you want to change the outline of the building, move the nodes. That way history and existing tags are maintained.

87843509

Hi, welcome to OpenStreetMap!
When you set tiger:reviewed to yes in your edits, please make sure that you have changed the highway tag to the correct designation. The import made a lot ways tagged as highway=residential, when they should be highway=track, highway=service, or highway=unclassified. There's a checklist on https://map.bingo/2020/01/14/openstreetmap-clean-up-after-tiger/ written by a local mapper that you can use as a guide.

87826874

Hi, welcome to OpenStreetMap!
In this edit, you added the name "Private Road" to a way. Is that the actual name of the road, or is it just an unnamed private road? If it is an unnamed private road, then the access should be set to private. Please see osm.wiki/Names#Names_are_not_for_descriptions for more info.

87814182

Hi, please review highway=service. This way is clearly serving this resort and ought to have the highway=service tag, not highway=track.

87820256

Hi,
Please do not change surface=asphalt to surface=paved unless the original tag was a mistake. surface=paved is an umbrella that covers asphalt, concrete, paving stones, and cobblestone. The most specific tag known should always be used, and it's clear from street level imagery that those ways have asphalt surfaces.

87547053

Hi, I have a few questions about this edit. Is this course open to the public? And are there route markings on the ground?

87419711

Welcome to OpenStreetMap.
You have deleted a whole bunch of ways that represent objects that are visible on aerial imagery. You deleted driveways, rock walls, and class vi roads that are clearly visible. The evidence is stacked against your actions. Can you prove that this isn't vandalism?

87364133

Welcome to OpenStreetMap. Please consult the wiki on proper tagging procedures. Relevant pages for this edit included but are not limited to highway=*#Roads and osm.wiki/Relation:route#Road_routes. I reverted this edit because you broke too many things, and the breaking outweighed the good additions by a lot. Specifically, you got the highway and ref tags of most of the ways in this edit incorrect, and you broke several relations.

87301773

Really dirt hiking paths can have highway=footway, but only if hiking is the only use. Since most trails allow horses, mountain bikes, and skiers, highway=path is correct more often.

78460663

Found to be incorrect on survey. Please be more careful when adding access=private.

81224545

Found to be incorrect on survey. Please be more careful when adding access=private.

78774043

Found to be incorrect on survey. Please be more careful when adding access=private.

86969057

Access at a public place cannot be private

86797305

Ah, on second look it seems like people just ignore the "authorized personnel only" signs and go around. From the Strava heatmap, it looks like people cut through near the Amazon building and leave the area at Massasoit Road.

Still, airport employees are allowed to use it, and the gates do open, so access=private is more correct. I just went through and found all of the gates and added access=private between the gates.

86943543

Hi,
As you are reviewing these ways for that MapRoulette challenge, please don't forget to fix the `highway` tag! Ways like this should be track roads.
Happy Mapping