Hey John, I've noticed a few times like with Hilton Sydney, Ibis King Street Wharf, you've removed tourism=hotel when adding building=hotel. The tourism=hotel key must remain for current hotels, building=hotel just means that the building was originally built as a hotel/it is a hotel building.

Yeah you're right, thank for spotting. I just fixed it.

Good catch, I see you've fixed it already, thank you.

Please see osm.wiki/Spam#SEO_Spam, if you're a legitimate business trying to improve OSM but would like some help, feel free to reply, but in the meantime I'll revert your change due to the marketing hype.

I know you've tried to fix this now but what's your source for your edits? Are you doing a ground survey? If you're armchair mapping, then please could you join talk-au or https://bit.ly/maptimeau to discuss changes first?

It would be great to have some help mapping to the public transport schema.

Ah thanks, you're right way/679354513/ is the public_transport=station and way/34891023 is the railway=station, per the wiki, one is more the passenger's view of the station, and the other the train's view of the station.

I don't think your T4 stop_area makes sense to me, but then again I don't really understand the stop_area tag...

Platform 24/25 are just two platforms at Central station, I don't think the need to be marked differently to any other platform at Central station.

Looks great, I just added the office=publisher tag from office=* so that this feature is marked as a publishers office.

Thanks, if that park is designed just for dogs, you can consider using leisure=dog_park

Thank you.

Hey there, I've added the new node node/6571334825 for Central station, however Central station was already mapped at way/34891023 as an area. Per one read world feature = one OSM object, we should only have one Central railway=station, and I think it should be the area. Could we delete the one you added and replace it from the relations with the way?

I've reverted this change, please discuss if you feel otherwise.

Actually sorry but this change doesn't line up with what's on the ground https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/xcdpbXlGLaxxj6tA_wI9kA, this isn't a road on the eastern side of the road, it's just the light rail track.

It looked like you could still access the western side of George St from Bond St, barrier aside, https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/qlLrcZuqUCMahVeyQghGnA time will tell if it should actually be connected or not.

This is okay, https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/L-6r2vO0kBssTzd6tdvR2w but you're right that once the light rail starts this isn't really highway=pedestrian anymore

Hey mate, I surveyed this on the weekend and on the section outside QVB, there was only a road from Hilton to Park St, not on the north end. See https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/TBj3My8YjHcZ2zU-C4B0UQ

Then outside Sydney Town Halla again there was no road on the north end. https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/PTBWvbGYIsTC7QQ9jfrl5g https://www.mapillary.com/map/im/kZzz6HFF5SkfutV5PDjYHw

With that in mind I've changed this back. Also I noticed you've accidentally snapped nodes between underground and above ground features.

could you please explain why you've removed name:etymology?

http://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/node/911561234

fixed in changeset/72005869

fixed in changeset/72005527

Hey there, I don't think it's fair to the original mapper to simply delete these tags, it's better to add in the information in another way. eg. adding in the bbqs.

Hi, according to the NSW Geographical Names Board, this park is named Edna Dunn Reserve, assigned 1st Feb 2019.