aharvey's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 30563007 | ditto node/3482883980 |
|
| 30563007 | node/3482883979 same question about isced level 0 |
|
| 30491804 | ditto way/251561861 |
|
| 30491804 | node/3477989701 same question about isced level 0 |
|
| 30843147 | node/343601250 same question about isced level 0 |
|
| 31227736 | same question about node/3523591264 |
|
| 31228303 | way/345716013/history isced level 0-1? 0 is preschool, but grades according to the nsw schools data say its only K-6. |
|
| 30300720 | node/3462833321 isced:level of 0 means preschool, the nsw schools database says it's K-6 does this cater for pre kinder kids? |
|
| 44072954 | Primary schools are usually operated by the Department of Education, normally only preschools are operated by the local council, so this school is really operated by the local council? |
|
| 31388676 | way/254796555/history isced:level 0 is preschool, the NSW Public Schools database says this is only K-6 which is isced:level 1. Do you have local knowledge of this? |
|
| 31944593 | node/3592233612/history you've set the isced:level as 0-1. In Australia 0 is preschool, before primary school. Are you sure this school includes preschool, under Kindergarten? The NSW Public Schools database says it only starts at Kindergarten. |
|
| 21296007 | Based on the LPI Suburb boundaries, Strahfield South High School appears to be in the suburb "Strathfield", you entered this school as being in "Strathfield South", are you sure about that? |
|
| 58335428 | Yeah this change looks correct according to the GNB record, but the GNB isn't always reflecting what's currently on the ground. https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=-33.79807777777779&lng=151.28864722222215&z=17&pKey=GeypGcKiQQhVzeTiybhU2A&focus=photo&x=0.2722288291602708&y=0.4698092965946888&zoom=0.8087487283825024 says South Steyne but it's unclear what it's referring too... |
|
| 58251817 | This looks like a good start, I think it's okay for the building outlines to be rough initially, anyone is free to improve if they like. Just as @nevw said why were a bunch of buildings deleted? It's okay to delete them if they were demolished, but that's about the only case they should be removed. If they are not "important" it's still okay to be in OSM if they are standing. |
|
| 58251817 | PS. Your edits go live immediately, there is no approval process. |
|
| 58335428 | Are you absolutely sure about this? Wikipedia says "From north to south, the three main sections are Queenscliff, North Steyne, and South Steyne" which could imply the whole thing is Manly Beach, with that bottom section being South Steyne Beach. |
|
| 58358891 | I have no issue with aggressively removing future edits which look like this, as it appears they are using a Geocoder to get the location, which we likely can't include the derived information from. Someone who has local knowledge would never put it in the wrong suburb! |
|
| 49044200 | sport=cricket_nets has over 1000 usages https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/sport=cricket_nets. Even though there is some debate about it's use, I think it's better to use that tag, and drop the descriptive name tag. |
|
| 58431694 | +1 indierokkr, only taking the sporting fields as leisure=pitch inside a leisure=park makes sense here. |
|
| 58303772 | Nice work here. A question, what is way/399566412 is it a hall, classrooms, administrative section? I'm not sure amenity=townhall is the best tag here. just building=school would probably suffice. |