OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
146850025

??? Eh? No motor vehicle parking spaces were changed to areoways. Your changes may be well intentioned but.. think about it!

The intention was to change ways with areoway=parking_position to areoways=apron. A parking position should be a stationary spot? Not the way to the stationary spot.

aeroway=parking_position – Where the plane parks

The presentness areoway=gate are wrong - those should be inside the terminal where passengers go before they enter the plane. These 'gates' are the plane parking positions!

Think.

146896571

node/11572336916 deleted.

This appears to be a duplication of existing Node: Stand F, Epping Station, Beecroft Rd (1170757338)

146897585

The bus stops added to route 549 are;

Not in sequential order

Have no relationship role

141973354

A 'platform' is beside the road/rail track...
A 'stop position' is on the road/rail track...

See public_transport=*#Stop_position

"on the way" meaning on the road/tail line...

'platform' where passengers wait - not on the road/train line..

146817570

Hi,
When you add a bus stop - such as node 11563923368 it should be tagged highway=bus_stop (for rendering) and for PTv2 public_transport=platform, bus=yes. Not doing this throws errors.

146843901

PTv2 requires;
'stops' to be before the train tracks
and
'stops' to be in sequence.

You should fix this simple error so you know what to do for next time.

146560953

When you make a multipolygon relation the members do not have to be new blank ways - you can use existing ways no matter what tags they use;
An existing building can be used as an inner in the relation
A lake could be used as an inner .. or even an outer.
and many other things.. they can all be used in the relation ...

This reduces your work load AND reduces data bloat in OSM.

99742404

3 year and still have crossing buildings...

125412795

The path Way: 1089492851... it cross the rail way line ... mist be either under ground or on a bridge... It also crosses a retaining wall...

146814464

Bus route 199 is not compliant with PTv2 - reset to PTv1

146742567

Hi,Please use the lifestyle prefix for demolished... see osm.wiki/Lifecycle_prefix#Stages_of_decay

146801040

Relation 3423234 - bus route 549 from Parramatta still has ways out of sequence. I have not checked the stops.

relation/3423235 546 from Parramatta is of for ways in sequence.

146732313

Relation deleted.

118898419

Hi,

The OSM guide is 'one feature=one OSM entry" So the single 'social facility' is one entry on the property boundary - the individual buildings within the boundary do not get the same tags.

Next addr:street is for the name of the street not the complete address including the number, post code etc.

This has been corrected.

146732049

Hi
Realtionships should not carry the same tags as the members ...
So building=apartments on the ways should not appear within the relation ...
This error has been corrected.

146767837

The same comment applies to bus route 3423234 bus route 549...

146767837

relation/3423235 - 546 bus route is once again broken. The only mapper making the changes that broke the route is you.

Will you please fix it so you can learn how not to brake these Public Transport version 2 routes???

See
https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=pubtrans_routes&lon=151.02734&lat=-33.77448&zoom=14&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&overlays=ptv2_routes_valid%2Cptv2_routes_invalid%2Cptv2_error_ways%2Cptv2_error_nodes%2Cptv2_routes_valid%2Cptv2_routes_invalid%2Cptv2_error_ways%2Cptv2_error_nodes

@Warin61/diary/45106

146775056

Hi
Multipolygon outer ways cannot share segments... For more information see osm.wiki/Relation:multipolygon

146730079

Hi,
The multipolygon relation is not 'correct'. The role 'inner' cannot touch a role 'outer'.

To me it looks like the red roof is one building ... then the other structure is ??? For the moment I have used the same tags on both, building=school, building:levels=2

You can check the osmwiki to see how tags are used - see osm.wiki/Relation:multipolygon

146731774

Same comment on this relation.

Hints:
Your probably reading this via some email message ... so
You can view the changeset on changeset/146731774
That gives you all the ways, relations and nodes that were entered or changed .. so you can see then there.
Then you can click on them to see each one .. such as the relation
relation/17086425

And so on for each thing.

For information on tags and relations the osmwiki is a reasonable guide. See
osm.wiki/Relation:multipolygon#Multipolygon_created_by_only_one_polygon
Note: engage brain, the wiki reflects the view of the person who last edited it, may not be a consensus view .. if you have concerns see the discussion page - top left provides a link to it on all the osmwiki pages.

Keep mapping.